DCP's ongoing problem with plagiarism

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: DCP's ongoing problem with plagiarism

Post by Marcus »

McClellan recently accused Wes Huff, a Christian apologist who currently holds the title of Central Canada Director for Apologetics Canada, of plagiarism.

People have started looking into this, and I find it fascinating that Dan Peterson's plagiarism techniques are nothing new. Here's an analysis from one reader:
Decided to plug a couple of Huff's other papers into an LLM to look for close matches to preexisting uncited literature. Like any AI analysis, this should be taken with the appropriate grain of salt, but: His 2018 paper "Who Came First: The Antioch Incident and a Textual Evaluation of ηλθον or ηλθεν in Galatians 2:12" appears to be a virtual carbon copy of David I. Yoon's 2014 paper "The Antioch Incident and a Textual Variant: “ΗΛΘΟΝ” or “ΗΛΘΕΝ” in Galatians 2:12," which it never cites. It makes the same distinctive arguments, structured in the same way, citing all the same sources in the same order.

Huff mostly paraphrases rather than directly lifting verbatim text (though he does seem to have verbatim taken some lines from Yoon's source, Stephen Carlson)—but it appears to be a beat-for-beat rewrite of Yoon at a level of granularity that cannot possibly be coincidence. And, of course, it is not at all believable that Huff's research would not have come across a paper on his exact very niche topic published four years prior.

Slightly less egregiously, Huff's paper on forgiveness in Luke-Acts seems to have some significant unattributed borrowing from a 2010 paper by Nathan Eubanks, though in that instance Huff does at least cite Eubanks elsewhere.

Needless to say, an actual subject-matter expert (which I am not) should review both papers—and the rest of Huff's work—but at least prima facie it looks like the plagiarism McClellan demonstrated is part of a pattern rather than an isolated incident. Which, of course, is usually the case with misconduct like this.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Christianity/c ... ybs50u7s5/
Several more features of plagiarism have been adocumented by readers, and not coincidentally, DCP's plagiarism has been proven by showing similarly copied and repeated errors:
Joseph Smith-normative:

Smoking gun: Yoon misspells the name of prominent 20th century Bible scholar T.W. Manson as "Mantin"—and Huff reproduces the error. This is the kind of mistake that's basically only possible if Huff never even looked at the original source he claimed to be extensively analyzing...

https://www.reddit.com/r/Christianity/c ... 0e9hj0fs5/

Kinslayer817:

Same thing for when he replicates mistaken page references from the original paper, there's no way that that can be a coincidence...

https://www.reddit.com/r/Christianity/c ... fi25nfc9v/
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: DCP's ongoing problem with plagiarism

Post by drumdude »

McClellan pointed out that this is yet another example of apologists getting a degree so that they appear to have authority to go against scholarly consensus. In other words, buying a degree so they can spread misinformation. LDS apologists did this exact same thing with Egyptology.

As Dan has shown with his Potemkin journal Interpreter, It’s easier than ever to have your misinformation seem so authoritative that is misleads countless gullible followers online.
Post Reply