Limnor wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 12:11 amIdentical? Ouch.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:43 pmYou’re accepting at face value second or third hand accounts from people with a vested interest in presenting him that way. I don’t think you’d accept that kind of thing as valid for anything that didn’t point to something you already wanted to believe.
…snip…
I tend to agree. Religious people are not open to normal enquiry and suggestion if the outcome runs contrary to what it is they have chosen to believe.
I think that’s a fair distinction. The only writing I’m aware of about the resurrection is that which we find in the Bible. But I take the content of the Bible with a pinch of salt, not literally. My thought is that the writers whose writing was selected for inclusion in that compilation would use allegorical presentations. Would the followers of Jesus not really have recognised him just three days after they last saw him? I’m not convinced by the narrative, and I can see no reason to conclude that a person can be dead for three days and come back to life. I know there are relatively recent examples of people seemingly coming back to life, but who were not deceased in the first place. I could see that mistake being the case for Jesus, and then him scarpering into hiding to avoid the Romans finishing the job.I think there is a difference in that evidence directly points away from Joseph and his claims whereas there isn’t evidence of plagiarism or other contrary evidence against resurrection. At least to my knowledge—if you have anything please let me know.
That’s fair enough.I do agree that if I wanted to pretend to believe something like Joseph’s claims I could do so. But it would be pretending. The explanation about human nature and the need for salvation in the New Testament has had a powerful impact on my understanding as well. I’m not pretending about that—those explanations make a lot of sense to me.
That’s fair enough. But the objective evidence runs contrary to your chosen belief. You are making it fit what you have chosen to believe. If God is capable of intervening in your life to give you peace etc then there needs to be an explanation for why he chooses to not do that for, say, victims of child abuse. Where was he during The Holocaust? How do you rationalise that he was there for you in your situation, but not there for them in theirs?One objection I’d have to your characterization is the “face value” comment. I’ve acknowledged that the accounts have uncertain authorship, that the Gospel writers, whoever they were, probably shaped their accounts around Hebrew scripture, and that alternative explanations for resurrection experiences cannot be ruled out. Those are substantial challenges that I’ve taken into account.
Limnor, Matthew describes something extraordinary happening immediately after Jesus dies - An earthquake occurs. Rocks split apart. Tombs open. Dead holy people are raised to life. After Jesus' resurrection, these people enter Jerusalem and appear to many people.
51 And, behold, the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom; and the earth did quake, and the rocks rent;
52 And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose,
53 And came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared unto many.
The astonishing part is that none of the other three Gospels mentions this event. Neither Mark, Luke nor John mentions dozens or potentially hundreds of dead people coming back to life and appearing in Jerusalem. If this happened literally, it would arguably be one of the most extraordinary public events in Jerusalem's history. Yet we have no independent contemporary account of it.
There is also a scholarly argument that Matthew constructed this passage using earlier Jewish apocalyptic traditions with which he was familiar. New Testament scholar Ronald Troxel specifically argues that Matthew created this scene, drawing on imagery from 1 Enoch.
Do you find Mathew’s account of multiple resurrections credible?
Mark is widely credited as being the first gospel account written, albeit many years after the death of Jesus. The earliest recoverable ending of Mark is generally considered to be Mark 16:8. It ends with the women discovering the empty tomb, being told that Jesus has risen, and fleeing in fear. The Gospel ends with "They said nothing to anyone, because they were afraid." There are no appearances of the resurrected Jesus in this original ending. The longer ending, Mark 16:9–20, which includes appearances of Jesus, is absent from the two earliest complete Greek manuscripts of Mark and is widely regarded as a later addition. So the idea that Jesus was resurrected was an embellishment. I think that reduces the likelihood that it actually happened.
For reference. It looks to me that Mark wrote something which was later added to making it more miraculous. The other 3 gospels, all written later, seem to me to be just embellishments of Mark.