Those Were the Days.

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
User avatar
Rivendale
God
Posts: 2030
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2021 5:21 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Rivendale »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 7:13 pm
Rivendale wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 6:11 pm
The usual apologetics for failed prophecies or troublesome commentary has several forms. Its symbolic. It hasn't come to pass yet. That was spiritual meaning. The Hebrew version was very clear about the text and if it did indeed mean that it they would have said that. Words don't mean words. You have to take it in context. All of this makes as much sense as paying your tithing spiritually.
I don’t disagree with any of this as being convenient. But I think the epistemic point, if there is any one thing that would cancel out, for me, would be whether Jesus was actually raised bodily from the dead. I think faith could survive symbolic interpretations, but the resurrection is different. If Jesus wasn’t actually raised from the dead, then there is no real victory over death. I realize that the historical evidence only demonstrates that Jesus’ followers “believed” he was raised, that there are alternative explanations, and I acknowledge those alternatives can’t be ruled out definitively. Plus I wouldn’t say that belief is proof, either, it’s just witness evidence.

I also recognize the similarity between my approach and MG’s. We both seem willing to allow for uncertainty and deviate from traditional interpretations. The difference I think is that I can identify a breaking point: If the bodily resurrection didn’t happen, my faith would lose its foundation. I don’t think MG has a breaking point regarding Joseph and the Restoration, or whether there is anything that would change his conclusions.
It was common for people to claim to be the resurrected person of a deceased person. Nero one of the more famous. One was so convincing that he convinced armies to go to battle and was eventually executed.

My question is, if the Resurrection was granted how do we make the leap it was supernatural? There are many naturalistic explanations that are far more probable.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Limnor »

Sure, there may be naturalistic explanations. The disciples could have been mistaken or even deliberately lied about what they experienced. But at the end of the day, I believe them. I recognize that belief isn’t proof, and I wouldn’t expect anyone else to accept it just because I do.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4580
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by I Have Questions »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:55 am
Sure, there may be naturalistic explanations. The disciples could have been mistaken or even deliberately lied about what they experienced. But at the end of the day, I believe them. I recognize that belief isn’t proof, and I wouldn’t expect anyone else to accept it just because I do.
Why do you believe that a man 2,000 years ago came back from the dead, but don’t believe that another man 200 years ago had some actual ancient gold plates that he found as a result of a miraculous interaction with an angel, say?
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Limnor »

I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:44 am
Limnor wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 12:55 am
Sure, there may be naturalistic explanations. The disciples could have been mistaken or even deliberately lied about what they experienced. But at the end of the day, I believe them. I recognize that belief isn’t proof, and I wouldn’t expect anyone else to accept it just because I do.
Why do you believe that a man 2,000 years ago came back from the dead, but don’t believe that another man 200 years ago had some actual ancient gold plates that he found as a result of a miraculous interaction with an angel, say?
This is difficult. Though I think the most difficult part is answering the question, “Why do I believe Jesus was resurrected?”

I’m trying to think through the order of things, or even whether there “is” an order. Do I believe in the resurrection because I believe in and trust God, or do I trust God because I believe the resurrection happened? Jesus said, in effect, “You trust God. Now trust me.” Maybe the two have reinforced one another over time. I’ve experienced what I understand to be God’s presence, a peace and a sense that someone is looking after me. I recognize that a Mormon “testimony” performs a similar function.

Fulfilled prophecy, particularly the suffering servant of Isaiah 53 and the idea of a Messiah ben Joseph, is something I’d point to. Though I’d acknowledge that the resurrection itself relies largely on testimony preserved in writings whose authorship are debatable.

As to Joseph Smith’s account, I find multiple reasons not to trust his story, particularly when examining the development of his claims and the 19th century context of the Book of Mormon.

So maybe the simplest answer is one of trust. And maybe that trust isn't something I generated myself, but something God gave me. Which reminds me of: “No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him.” That’s why I don’t think any argument could convince someone else.
User avatar
Rivendale
God
Posts: 2030
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2021 5:21 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Rivendale »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:17 pm
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:44 am
Why do you believe that a man 2,000 years ago came back from the dead, but don’t believe that another man 200 years ago had some actual ancient gold plates that he found as a result of a miraculous interaction with an angel, say?
This is difficult. Though I think the most difficult part is answering the question, “Why do I believe Jesus was resurrected?”

I’m trying to think through the order of things, or even whether there “is” an order. Do I believe in the resurrection because I believe in and trust God, or do I trust God because I believe the resurrection happened? Jesus said, in effect, “You trust God. Now trust me.” Maybe the two have reinforced one another over time. I’ve experienced what I understand to be God’s presence, a peace and a sense that someone is looking after me. I recognize that a Mormon “testimony” performs a similar function.

Fulfilled prophecy, particularly the suffering servant of Isaiah 53 and the idea of a Messiah ben Joseph, is something I’d point to. Though I’d acknowledge that the resurrection itself relies largely on testimony preserved in writings whose authorship are debatable.

As to Joseph Smith’s account, I find multiple reasons not to trust his story, particularly when examining the development of his claims and the 19th century context of the Book of Mormon.

So maybe the simplest answer is one of trust. And maybe that trust isn't something I generated myself, but something God gave me. Which reminds me of: “No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him.” That’s why I don’t think any argument could convince someone else.
Thanks for the scriptures reference. This seems to be one of the scriptures that has been fiercely debated both by believers and non-believers. What do you think of Bart Erhman's opinion regarding why Isaiah 53 sounds so much like Jesus? In short he thinks the similarity is because the writers of the gospels were deeply familiar with those scriptures and they knew them inside and out. When they told stories about Jesus's life and death they told them in a way as to fulfill those prophecies. Fascinating stuff.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4580
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by I Have Questions »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:17 pm
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:44 am
Why do you believe that a man 2,000 years ago came back from the dead, but don’t believe that another man 200 years ago had some actual ancient gold plates that he found as a result of a miraculous interaction with an angel, say?
This is difficult. Though I think the most difficult part is answering the question, “Why do I believe Jesus was resurrected?”

I’m trying to think through the order of things, or even whether there “is” an order. Do I believe in the resurrection because I believe in and trust God, or do I trust God because I believe the resurrection happened? Jesus said, in effect, “You trust God. Now trust me.” Maybe the two have reinforced one another over time. I’ve experienced what I understand to be God’s presence, a peace and a sense that someone is looking after me. I recognize that a Mormon “testimony” performs a similar function.
Not similar, identical.
Fulfilled prophecy, particularly the suffering servant of Isaiah 53 and the idea of a Messiah ben Joseph, is something I’d point to. Though I’d acknowledge that the resurrection itself relies largely on testimony preserved in writings whose authorship are debatable.
Well yes. You’re accepting at face value second or third hand accounts from people with a vested interest in presenting him that way. I don’t think you’d accept that kind of thing as valid for anything that didn’t point to something you already wanted to believe.
As to Joseph Smith’s account, I find multiple reasons not to trust his story, particularly when examining the development of his claims and the 19th century context of the Book of Mormon.
I think, if you wanted to, you could make the justification for believing in Joseph Smith in the same way as your reasoning for belief in the resurrection.
So maybe the simplest answer is one of trust. And maybe that trust isn't something I generated myself, but something God gave me. Which reminds me of: “No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him.” That’s why I don’t think any argument could convince someone else.
I tend to agree. Religious people are not open to normal enquiry and suggestion if the outcome runs contrary to what it is they have chosen to believe.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Limnor »

Rivendale wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:39 pm
Thanks for the scriptures reference. This seems to be one of the scriptures that has been fiercely debated both by believers and non-believers. What do you think of Bart Erhman's opinion regarding why Isaiah 53 sounds so much like Jesus? In short he thinks the similarity is because the writers of the gospels were deeply familiar with those scriptures and they knew them inside and out. When they told stories about Jesus's life and death they told them in a way as to fulfill those prophecies. Fascinating stuff.
I think Ehrman is interesting and agree with him that whoever wrote the gospels was very familiar with the Hebrew scriptures and obviously were influenced by and interpreted Jesus’ life and death through them . But I think there’s a difference between interpreting what happened through that lens and inventing things to create fulfillment.

I’m not convinced by Ehrman’s identification of the suffering servant as the nation of Israel collectively. Isaiah 49:3 identifies the servant as Israel, but verses 5–6 describe that same servant as restoring Israel to God. That seems to indicate there is an individual servant and the people he restores. I think when you look at the biblical story as a whole, the servant represents Israel as an individual, a descendant or seed, rather than the nation collectively. A great nation is supposed to be the result of the seed.

What’s also interesting is that Jewish tradition, even before Christ, showed an expectation of a messianic figure. There’s even a suffering servant interpretation—Messiah ben Joseph—alongside the Messiah ben David concept.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Limnor »

I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:43 pm
You’re accepting at face value second or third hand accounts from people with a vested interest in presenting him that way. I don’t think you’d accept that kind of thing as valid for anything that didn’t point to something you already wanted to believe.

…snip…

I tend to agree. Religious people are not open to normal enquiry and suggestion if the outcome runs contrary to what it is they have chosen to believe.
Identical? Ouch.

I think there is a difference in that evidence directly points away from Joseph and his claims whereas there isn’t evidence of plagiarism or other contrary evidence against resurrection. At least to my knowledge—if you have anything please let me know.

I do agree that if I wanted to pretend to believe something like Joseph’s claims I could do so. But it would be pretending. The explanation about human nature and the need for salvation in the New Testament has had a powerful impact on my understanding as well. I’m not pretending about that—those explanations make a lot of sense to me.

One objection I’d have to your characterization is the “face value” comment. I’ve acknowledged that the accounts have uncertain authorship, that the Gospel writers, whoever they were, probably shaped their accounts around Hebrew scripture, and that alternative explanations for resurrection experiences cannot be ruled out. Those are substantial challenges that I’ve taken into account.
huckelberry
God
Posts: 4129
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by huckelberry »

Rivendale wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:04 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 7:13 pm
I don’t disagree with any of this as being convenient. But I think the epistemic point, if there is any one thing that would cancel out, for me, would be whether Jesus was actually raised bodily from the dead. I think faith could survive symbolic interpretations, but the resurrection is different. If Jesus wasn’t actually raised from the dead, then there is no real victory over death. I realize that the historical evidence only demonstrates that Jesus’ followers “believed” he was raised, that there are alternative explanations, and I acknowledge those alternatives can’t be ruled out definitively. Plus I wouldn’t say that belief is proof, either, it’s just witness evidence.

I also recognize the similarity between my approach and MG’s. We both seem willing to allow for uncertainty and deviate from traditional interpretations. The difference I think is that I can identify a breaking point: If the bodily resurrection didn’t happen, my faith would lose its foundation. I don’t think MG has a breaking point regarding Joseph and the Restoration, or whether there is anything that would change his conclusions.
It was common for people to claim to be the resurrected person of a deceased person. Nero one of the more famous. One was so convincing that he convinced armies to go to battle and was eventually executed.

My question is, if the Resurrection was granted how do we make the leap it was supernatural? There are many naturalistic explanations that are far more probable.
Rivendale. I can respect your caution. I do note that Jesus disappeared unlike the Nero standins. Of course that may only mean he was really dead. Much of the resurrection belief can appear to be based upon visions of him in supernatural power. It is even possible visions were the primary basis for the belief. I do know of an objective way to be sure of that.
huckelberry
God
Posts: 4129
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by huckelberry »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:47 pm
Rivendale wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:39 pm
Thanks for the scriptures reference. This seems to be one of the scriptures that has been fiercely debated both by believers and non-believers. What do you think of Bart Erhman's opinion regarding why Isaiah 53 sounds so much like Jesus? In short he thinks the similarity is because the writers of the gospels were deeply familiar with those scriptures and they knew them inside and out. When they told stories about Jesus's life and death they told them in a way as to fulfill those prophecies. Fascinating stuff.
I think Ehrman is interesting and agree with him that whoever wrote the gospels was very familiar with the Hebrew scriptures and obviously were influenced by and interpreted Jesus’ life and death through them . But I think there’s a difference between interpreting what happened through that lens and inventing things to create fulfillment.

I’m not convinced by Ehrman’s identification of the suffering servant as the nation of Israel collectively. Isaiah 49:3 identifies the servant as Israel, but verses 5–6 describe that same servant as restoring Israel to God. That seems to indicate there is an individual servant and the people he restores. I think when you look at the biblical story as a whole, the servant represents Israel as an individual, a descendant or seed, rather than the nation collectively. A great nation is supposed to be the result of the seed.

What’s also interesting is that Jewish tradition, even before Christ, showed an expectation of a messianic figure. There’s even a suffering servant interpretation—Messiah ben Joseph—alongside the Messiah ben David concept.
Limnor, N.T. Wright proposes that the first meaning of the Isaiah suffering servant is Israel. Israel only partially fulfilled the calling. It is brought to a greater fulfillment in Jesus. There is no need or point in rejecting or ignoring the Israel as suffering servant understanding. I don't think Wright is the only person to see it that way. I do not think the story of Jesus needs to have adjustments to make the connection. It is clear the suffering servant deeply influenced how believers understood Jesus.
Post Reply