NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
Shulem
God
Posts: 8980
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:40 am
Location: Facsimile No. 3

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Shulem »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:04 am
I’ve long thought that “Olimlah” represented Oliver, as Joseph’s slave.
Sorry, that just does not compute and makes no sense at all. Oliver was excommunicated in 1838 and lived in Ohio on his own terms as a nonmember of the church when the Book of Abraham was published in Nauvoo. I have a hard time imagining how the Second Elder of the Church who also served as Assistant President was considered Joseph's personal slave. That simply makes no sense!

Joseph Smith gave Oliver Cowdery a Patriarchal Blessing in 1835:
  • he shall be made like unto the bow which the Lord hath set in the heavens
  • he shall be a sign unto the nations
  • he has done like Abraham
  • He shall sit in the council of the patriarchs, with his brother Joseph
  • He shall be equal in the councils of Israel, for he shall sit in the great assemblys of the house of Jacob
  • He shall also stand in the councils of nations and states
  • in repute even by governors and kings, and stand in the legislatures of nations
etc.
Chap wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:47 am
Alas, no apologist will dare to answer ...
What about baby Smoot-boy? Do you suppose he would step in the ring and dance with me?

:lol:
Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 10, 2026 1:11 pm
Solving the “mystery” is the thing that keeps bringing me back. I think it’s fun and fascinating. Also, I can see the correlation to views about biblical history. I think the difference is Joseph’s methods are demonstrable.
Sounds like you're having fun and that makes it all worth it!

:)
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Limnor »

I’m not suggesting Oliver was literally Joseph’s slave. I’m suggesting Joseph may have been inserting people from his own experience into an ancient setting, assigning them symbolic roles. And I’m not sure the 1842 publication date settles anything. The Book of Abraham project started in 1835 and Oliver participated in the early translation work. It’s the common methodology that intrigues me most, that is, casting his companions into an ancient setting.

Consider D&C 28, where Oliver is instructed to be obedient to Joseph, just as Aaron was subordinate to Moses. He’s also told not to command Joseph, who is described as being at his head.

If Joseph was incorporating his own relationships into the Book of Abraham, as I suspect he did in the Book of Mormon, Olimlah would represent Oliver’s subordinate position as Joseph saw it.
User avatar
Shulem
God
Posts: 8980
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:40 am
Location: Facsimile No. 3

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Shulem »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:01 am
I’m not suggesting Oliver was literally Joseph’s slave. I’m suggesting Joseph may have been inserting people from his own experience into an ancient setting, assigning them symbolic roles. And I’m not sure the 1842 publication date settles anything. The Book of Abraham project started in 1835 and Oliver participated in the early translation work. It’s the common methodology that intrigues me most, that is, casting his companions into an ancient setting.
Oliver was a white man and it was illegal to enslave a white man in the US. It makes no sense to pretend he was ever a slave -- past, present, or future.
Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:01 am
Consider D&C 28, where Oliver is instructed to be obedient to Joseph, just as Aaron was subordinate to Moses. He’s also told not to command Joseph, who is described as being at his head.
Moses and Aaron rejected the very idea that either of them were slaves -- thus they overpowered the Egyptians and declared freedom. In similitude, it's impossible that Smith would have likened Cowdery as his slave.
Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:01 am
If Joseph was incorporating his own relationships into the Book of Abraham, as I suspect he did in the Book of Mormon, Olimlah would represent Oliver’s subordinate position as Joseph saw it.
No! Oliver was pure white. The black skin was a mark of the curse of Ham in which according to the Book of Abraham (chapter 1) Oliver would have had no right to the priesthood.

Oliver was not a slave in the mind of Joseph Smith! He was his right arm in the fellowship of white priesthood power. THAT *was* Mormonism!
Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:01 am
And I’m not sure the 1842 publication date settles anything. The Book of Abraham project started in 1835 and Oliver participated in the early translation work. It’s the common methodology that intrigues me most, that is, casting his companions into an ancient setting.
We agree that Oliver presented a great deal of commentary about the papyri purchased by the church and published those things under the direction of Joseph Smith. But nothing was ever said about Facsimile No. 3. Cowdery remained a member of the church for 2 years and 9 month after the papyri were first purchased before being excommunicated in April of 1838. So, Oliver had lost all his blessings and had nothing to do with the publication of the Book of Abraham in Nauvoo. Now, it's true that Joseph Smith later reached out to Oliver in 1843 by letter and pleaded with him to return to the fold and wear again his robes of righteousness, but nothing came of it until after the death of the prophet.

There is nothing in church history that leads us to believe that Smith would have likened his right arm man to that of a black slave. Negros were considered to be descendants of the cursed race via Ham & Cain. Oliver Cowdery would have rejected that comparison and Brigham Young would have probably beaten the hell out of Joseph Smith if he had ever likened him to a Negro! Can you imagine?
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Limnor »

I think you are taking my explanation a bit too literally.
User avatar
Shulem
God
Posts: 8980
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:40 am
Location: Facsimile No. 3

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Shulem »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:29 pm
I think you are taking my explanation a bit too literally.
I just don't think Joseph Smith would have likened Oliver Cowdery to that of an ancient Negro.
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Philo Sofee »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 10, 2026 1:11 pm
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 10, 2026 11:21 am
Joseph could also have been seeking to legitimise the march for his own authority by creating a precedent or foreshadow in something he could pass off as ancient scripture.
Absolutely. The precedent for that method is in the Book of Mormon in which translation, seership, and authority are connected, in Mosiah 8, which is a convenient precedent for the kind of authority Joseph was claiming. So Joseph wasn’t just writing himself into ancient history. He building an ancient foundation for his own authority, beginning with translation and seership as the core that later evolved into the priesthood.

Joseph and Oliver wrote about the need for authority to administer ordinances in the accounts of 1829, and the fully developed priesthood framework emerged over time. And Whitmer said that expanded authority had been sought partly to satisfy demands of members, and that the development of greater institutional power came from leaders who wanted more authority.

The Book of Abraham conveniently provides an ancient precedent to satisfy these demands. The parallel between Abraham and Joseph is reflected in the possession of records that document that authority. The rightful religious leader possesses the ancient records establishing his authority. In the Book of Abraham, that contest is between Pharaoh and Abraham, in the “real world,” I think that contest was between Joseph and Rigdon. And just for fun, I’ve played around with Mahmackrah as representing Martin Harris (Harris was identified as Mahemson in the D&C), and Korash as representing Newel Knight.

Solving the “mystery” is the thing that keeps bringing me back. I think it’s fun and fascinating. Also, I can see the correlation to views about biblical history. I think the difference is Joseph’s methods are demonstrable.
Oh yeah! ALL GREAT STUFF! No question I don't think Joseph wanted to be THE Seer. Greater than a prophet ya know. I mean, what do they actually do after all? Hold meetings now? GRIN!
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Limnor »

Philo Sofee wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 8:06 pm
Oh yeah! ALL GREAT STUFF! No question I don't think Joseph wanted to be THE Seer. Greater than a prophet ya know. I mean, what do they actually do after all? Hold meetings now? GRIN!
Thanks Philo. I’ve long been interested in the recurring theme of being “bound” throughout Joseph’s writings. In fact, I used the name Alma Bound years ago because of it. I’ve wondered whether Joseph, as much as he wanted to produce translations, also felt bound by the expectations and demands of his companions. In an allegorical symbolic reading, Alma the Elder represents Oliver Cowdery, bound to Joseph much as I suspect Olimlah represents Oliver in the Book of Abraham.

What’s interesting is that Abraham is described as being bound to the altar, yet Facsimile 1 doesn’t actually show him with restraints of any kind and I think that is telling. As in, maybe bondage represents more than physical restraint, reflecting expectations of obedience and struggles for authority among Joseph and his early companions.
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: NEW Refuting My Former Apologetic Self: Abraham as Astronomer. NOPE!

Post by Philo Sofee »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 1:09 am
Philo Sofee wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 8:06 pm
Oh yeah! ALL GREAT STUFF! No question I don't think Joseph wanted to be THE Seer. Greater than a prophet ya know. I mean, what do they actually do after all? Hold meetings now? GRIN!
Thanks Philo. I’ve long been interested in the recurring theme of being “bound” throughout Joseph’s writings. In fact, I used the name Alma Bound years ago because of it. I’ve wondered whether Joseph, as much as he wanted to produce translations, also felt bound by the expectations and demands of his companions. In an allegorical symbolic reading, Alma the Elder represents Oliver Cowdery, bound to Joseph much as I suspect Olimlah represents Oliver in the Book of Abraham.

What’s interesting is that Abraham is described as being bound to the altar, yet Facsimile 1 doesn’t actually show him with restraints of any kind and I think that is telling. As in, maybe bondage represents more than physical restraint, reflecting expectations of obedience and struggles for authority among Joseph and his early companions.
Oh.........do I see a light bulb going off above my own head here? I had not quite put that together before. COOL to think on, thanks for the suggestion and discussion Limnor.
Post Reply