Why do you think so? Is it either or?
Regards
MG
It can be a composite of both. Think of Charlie Harrell's book, "This Is My Doctrine: The Development of Mormon Theology." In his book we learn that "concepts " were developed and changed along the way from the initiation of the restoration of Christ's Church until now.Marcus wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:19 pmYes. it's one thing to specifically say "we understand it within our faith as [fill in faith based rationale]...." It's quite another to argue "only we and no one else can understand this concept."I Have Questions wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 7:27 pmTell me you’re a brainwashed member of a cult without telling me you’re a brainwashed member of a cult.
The other issue i have is the argument that this thing is from their god. Given the significant backtracking of lds 'prophetic' statements and the argument that 'our lds leaders are human and just as prone to mistakes as we are,' the unwillingness to consider that concepts within one's religion are manufactured by humans and could be wrong is not logical or rational.
No, I think I'm pretty much using the word testimony in a traditional sense
If you think about it, it explains a lot. Of course, there is the rest of what I said attached to that.Rivendale wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:44 pmI also have serious problems with the concept that god meets you where your at and then guides you.Marcus wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:19 pm
Yes. it's one thing to specifically say "we understand it within our faith as [fill in faith based rationale]...." It's quite another to argue "only we and no one else can understand this concept."
The other issue i have is the argument that this thing is from their god. Given the significant backtracking of lds 'prophetic' statements and the argument that 'our lds leaders are human and just as prone to mistakes as we are,' the unwillingness to consider that concepts within one's religion are manufactured by humans and could be wrong is not logical or rational.
I really will have to take exception to that. I do not think myself "elite" and would not consider myself "arrogant".I Have Questions wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:55 pmMG is okay with it because he’s arrogant and believes he’s one of the elite.Rivendale wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:44 pmThe inner circle claim that it somehow grants a superior understanding of appalling behavior is flat out elitist and arrogant. I will also never understand how MG is completely ok with a judgment based on a finite life where almost everything is dependent on the soil a person is placed in which is almost completely out of a person's control.
I didn't quite say that. Respectfully, I would ask you and others to go back and read what I actually said in context.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:55 pmHe has quite literally just informed everyone on the board that he is the only one here qualified to talk about Mormon doctrinal topics.
I have concerns for you IHQ. It's almost as if you don't actually read my posts. We've already been down this path. Why do you continue bringing this up? I've already responded, at length, to what seems to be a serious concern for you.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:59 pmIf he truly had a testimony he wouldn’t be wasting his time here avoiding discussing everything, he’d be serving a senior mission. So it’s clear he doesn’t have a strong testimony of what he professes to believe in. His lack of action undermines his words. He’s just here to play - just look at his post tally.
it can be a composite of both what? Both human-manufactured and wrong?MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:15 amIt can be a composite of both.Marcus wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:19 pm
Yes. it's one thing to specifically say "we understand it within our faith as [fill in faith based rationale]...." It's quite another to argue "only we and no one else can understand this concept."
The other issue i have is the argument that this thing is from their god. Given the significant backtracking of lds 'prophetic' statements and the argument that 'our lds leaders are human and just as prone to mistakes as we are,' the unwillingness to consider that concepts within one's religion are manufactured by humans and could be wrong is not logical or rational.
That doesn't address my point at all, unless you're admitting Mormon theology is based on nothing more than copying other humans.Think of Charlie Harrell's book, "This Is My Doctrine: The Development of Mormon Theology." In his book we learn that "concepts " were developed and changed along the way from the initiation of the restoration of Christ's Church until now.
Again, that doesn't address the point at all. it sounds like you put words into AI and told it to come up with a response. Your final question is nonsensical, except as a way to draw a bullseye around everything and ask if God did it. By that absurd logic, every religion is right, every evil doing came from god, and atheists are also correct.Mistakes and natural evolution are, at least at times, difficult to differentiate. The question one must ask is, "Is God in the middle of it all?"...
Hi Marcus, I don't see you as an honest broker in your last post. I would love to have a conversation with you without you resorting to old tactics. The newest of the old being "you put words into AI". I didn't.
Inevitably the "testimony" is invoked to avoid evidence, yes. It also amuses me how hard that ghost works to make sure he gives mg not only god statements but also shares everything about the state of mind of every other human being mg interacts with. Didn't that energizer bunny of a holy ghost get his spiritual HIPAA training about privacy?!?Gadianton wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:40 pmLatter-day Saints that claim to "have a testimony" -- it's more of a talking point from the sales literature than anything -- will naturally gather together and worship together. Then again, Latter-Day Saints who don't have a testimony will also gather together and worship together, as Boyd K. Packer instructed. Then again, Satanists naturally gather together and worship together even though there would be no spiritual witness under your view for them to benefit from.MG wrote: Latter-day Saints that have a testimony of the Restoration through Joseph Smith and on up to the current prophet/president Dallin Oaks will naturally gather together and worship together.
Your way of participating on this board strikes me as someone using a testimony for the sake of argument, as a means of avoiding evidence, rather than the effect of truly "having a testimony".
Lol. we were just discussing how evidence is avoided, and now mg has provided an object lesson.MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:01 amHi Marcus, I don't see you as an honest broker in your last post. I would love to have a conversation with you without you resorting to old tactics. The newest of the old being "you put words into AI". I didn't.
That really doesn't lend itself to good faith discussion.
We can try again next time around.
Take care and have a good weekend!![]()
Regards,
MG