New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Marcus »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 4:34 am
Shulem wrote:It's not a matter of envying anyone's life per-se. It's a matter of envying how they are able to choose whatever life they want to live and that was the point. Do you see the difference, MG? Just think how nice it would be to be able to choose how YOU want to live without a church telling you how you have to live with regard to all the dos and don'ts assigned by Mormonism. That was the point, I do believe.
I'm inclined to agree. I think there is reasonable envy here. I also agree with Marcus' point that MG thinks that we envy his life, given all the times he drops hints that he's going on a drive, or going out to eat with family, or doing some activity, as if nobody else but him eats or goes to a pool.
It's a staple of his communication. in my opinion, it's also a strongly supported lds concept. One of the more obvious examples was when Brad Wilcox was caught stating that other religions just "play church," the way children play make-believe games.
But here's the thing, I think MG knows his relativism cuts both ways. MG to a great extent has chosen how to live his life without obeying the higher commandments such as going on a senior mission. He justifies this with relativism. Everyone has their own path. But if that works, then he can't just pick and choose what "lifestyle choices" a person gets to make and still make it to the first degree of glory. Suppose the church really is true. It's quite possible that every one of the apostates on this board still can live a life of rebellion against MG's version of Mormonism and make the first degree of the Celestial kingdom. Perhaps we will "repent" in the next life. you can't easily pick and choose how "through a glass darkly" applies to individual lives. Just because he and his wife have "made their own decision" doesn't mean that my rebellion against "the Lord" is as unforgivable as MG wants to believe.

This may be the greatest test of believer psychology. If myself, Marcus, IHQ, and even Huck, perhaps the greatest apostate of us all,
:D :D :D
...can live our lives in rebellion of everything MG holds sacred and get off Scott free with it; the scriptural elucidation of this principle is the prodigal son. MG will truly blow a fuse when the Lord kills the fatted calf to welcome Marcus into his glory, and he'll have an eye on MG to test his jealousy.

MG's relativism is a barbed hook. The more he relies on it to justify his own free-wheeling, gray, interpretation of the commandments, the greater the possibility that the apostates who drive him nuts might continue in their ways through mortality and make it to the top anyway. He must suspect that he could shut the door to the unbeliever with greater certainty, and have his personal victory, should he himself live a more "black and white" interpretation of God's commands.
He must, at some level, but the lds church is very insular. If he starts being too rational he can run back and get a higher up priesthood holder to reassure him. Alternatively, he can come here and attempt to put others down to boost himself.

I am quite curious about what you called his "gray interpretation(s)." In my opinion some of his crazier non-lds concepts are provided by AI, but ultimately, yes, I agree it is a relativism he allows himself, but that clashes harshly with his black and white judgment of those he considers non-lds. Both can't be justified.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by MG 2.0 »

Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
If [MG] starts being too rational he can run back and get a higher up priesthood holder to reassure him.
Whaaat?
Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
Alternatively, he can come here and attempt to put others down to boost himself.
Marcus, you can do better and be better. Let's get it together. I respect you, but sometimes you make it difficult. But I'm trying!
Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
I am quite curious about what you called his "gray interpretation(s)." In my opinion some of his crazier non-lds concepts are provided by AI
And we're off to the races.
Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
I agree it is a relativism he allows himself, but that clashes harshly with his black and white judgment of those he considers non-lds.
Ya' got it wrong there sister.

Like I said a couple of days ago, things were different way back when. Marcus, did you ever know Truth Dancer (I think she also went by another name but I can't remember it right now). She was a good role model at the time for being kind and yet saying her 'truth to power' arguments.

It can be done. You can shine!

Regards,
MG
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Marcus »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:08 am
Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
If [MG] starts being too rational he can run back and get a higher up priesthood holder to reassure him.
Whaaat?
Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
Alternatively, he can come here and attempt to put others down to boost himself.
Marcus, you can do better and be better. Let's get it together. I respect you, but sometimes you make it difficult. But I'm trying!
Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
I am quite curious about what you called his "gray interpretation(s)." In my opinion some of his crazier non-lds concepts are provided by AI
And we're off to the races.
Marcus wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:49 pm
I agree it is a relativism he allows himself, but that clashes harshly with his black and white judgment of those he considers non-lds.
Ya' got it wrong there sister.

Like I said a couple of days ago, things were different way back when. Marcus, did you ever know Truth Dancer (I think she also went by another name but I can't remember it right now). She was a good role model at the time for being kind and yet saying her 'truth to power' arguments.

It can be done. You can shine!

Regards,
MG
lol . More avoidance of evidence. Here are the points under discussion:
Marcus wrote: ↑ in my opinion, it's also a strongly supported lds concept. One of the more obvious examples was when Brad Wilcox was caught stating that other religions just "play church," the way children play make-believe games...
MG's relativism is a barbed hook. The more he relies on it to justify his own free-wheeling, gray, interpretation of the commandments, the greater the possibility that the apostates who drive him nuts might continue in their ways through mortality and make it to the top anyway. He must suspect that he could shut the door to the unbeliever with greater certainty, and have his personal victory, should he himself live a more "black and white" interpretation of God's commands.
He must, at some level, but the lds church is very insular. If he starts being too rational he can run back and get a higher up priesthood holder to reassure him. Alternatively, he can come here and attempt to put others down to boost himself.

I am quite curious about what you called his "gray interpretation(s)." In my opinion some of his crazier non-lds concepts are provided by AI, but ultimately, yes, I agree it is a relativism he allows himself, but that clashes harshly with his black and white judgment of those he considers non-lds. Both can't be justified.
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Gadianton »

Marcus wrote:I am quite curious about what you called his "gray interpretation(s)."
MG is in an odd space. He grew up a "Dialogue" Mormon, but appears to have ticked the main boxes of mission, church on Sunday, temple marriage, and tithing of some sort. He appears through-and-through culturally Mormon.

But he denies that God has a body. He thinks tea is okay. He doesn't see a mission as a commandment. He participates on this board, which most leaders would discourage. As you point out, the relativism -- he's got down pat a gospel of "whatever is comfortable for me is probably right". Now, a lot of people are this way, but not so explicitly. Like my mom, she didn't go on a senior mission, but she had semi-valid excuses such as health and finances, and though I think these were somewhat flimsy, on the one hand, she'd convinced herself of it, and on the other, to the extent that she knew she was making excuses, she was quite guilt-ridden over matters like this. She was very concerned that her personal worthiness was not enough. MG, on the other hand, has all the confidence in the world that he's good to go, that whatever he feels like putting into it is good enough.

A bishop I had used to tell this story of a guy in history looking to hire someone to transport nitro-glycerine and asked his prospects while transporting his cargo by horse and wagon, how close they would venture to the edge of a cliff while taking on a tight bend. The punchline was he hired the guy who said, "I'd stay as far away from that edge as possible." This is the proper Chapel Mormon outlook. Someone who pays 10.2% on their gross just in case. MG, the "gymnast" is -- in his own mind -- an intellectual acrobat who can dance at the edge of the cliff all day without consequence.

His interpretation of Mormon history or doctrine is plagued by relativism that doesn't fit a Chapel Mormon perspective. Uncomfortable truths need to either be owned or rejected. For instance, the Nancy Rigdon event, my Dad fully embracing it as Joseph Smith the mighty prophet who commanded things that were too hard for the Saints to comply with. Others would reject it as an anti-Mormon lie. Either way, Joseph Smith is a larger-than-life model of pure righteousness. MG seems good with admitting to many sins of Mormon leaders, but other people were just as bad, or so what, if you want to make an omelet you've got to break some eggs.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
Post Reply