Here is a quote from mentalgymnast in one of the threads he linked to in his OP as being an example of the good old days when he engaged in polite and respectful conversation…
My experience has been that those individuals such as yourself whom have become permanently disaffected have become somewhat regimented in their thinking and a bit overboard in their judgements of others.
For MG’s benefit here is why this is problematic. Rather than addressing Guy's specific argument, MG makes a generalisation about people who have become disaffected. He characterises Guy's thinking as regimented. He suggests Guy is excessive in judging other people. He is dismissing someone's reasoning on the basis of their religious position or personal history. So even when MG attempts to give an example of his own good board behaviour, he links to examples of his own bad board behaviour. You could not make this up.
For MG’s benefit and education, a more graceful response would have addressed the particular argument without making assumptions about Guy's psychological or intellectual state.
Even his interactions with Truth Dancer fail to live up to his memory of them…
…you're right, you're not getting it. I don't know that I can be any more clear in what I've been trying to say throughout this thread.
…and…
Your statement above referring to all that I've said before being "close to saying" what you then said, is off kilter by more than a smidgen.
“You're right, you're not getting it" is dismissive. It places the responsibility for the communication failure entirely on the other participant. “Off kilter by more than a smidgen” is a belittling way of characterising someone's interpretation. It doesn't demonstrate much willingness to consider whether MG himself might have communicated his position unclearly.
That’s really quite rude and dismissive towards someone who had been genuinely trying hard to understand his perspective.
MG, I hope you will see the opportunity for your own personal growth even within the examples you’ve provided where you think you’ve interacted gracefully. And recognise that I’m genuinely trying to help you be your best self on this board.