Joe's Ranch

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Philo Sofee »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 7:57 pm
MG wrote:I actually would be quite interested in your knowledge/scholarship in this area. And if it lends credence to where you think Jesus met the thief after the crucifixion.

Doctrinally, it’s kind of a big deal, right?
I think this is explained away in A Marvelous Work and a Wonder, which was approved by the Church for missionary use so it's semi-official. What Jesus meant was spirit paradise, vs. spirit prison. The thief would still need to get all his paperwork sorted out and a more thorough repentance to make the Celestial Kingdom.

It sounds natural to members growing up with the doctrines set up and ready to go. It makes no sense otherwise. There is no reason to believe Jesus believed in some complex set of realms.
As I have been looking at this since it has become a topic of conversation and I am really liking McClellen's whole approach to the Bible these days (alas! I get older), here is what I see with it. Subject to revision as I learn more, but of course. I would be cautious about claiming that Jesus was teaching a fully developed doctrine of heaven, spirit paradise, and spirit prison in Luke 23. There is just nothing in the text that could justify imagining a systematic theology on Jesus' part here. Heh, we could say that for the entire New Testament though, couldn't we.....

What we see in the text is a promise of immediate blessed companionship with Jesus, Nowhere is there a geography of the afterlife mentioned or discussed or analyzed by anyone on the cross or the ground.

Looking at it with just regular eyes we can also see that Luke 23:43 promises paradise when the guy dies. But actually, other New Testament passages emphasize resurrection at the end of the age. Whatever resurrection means (Margaret Barker blew the doors off my LDS understanding when I read her theological interpretations) and whatever the end of the age may mean. If we look, I'm willing to bet we can find at least 5 other types of interpretations that do not all agree or cohere into a systematic rational logical view.

If we approach this historically, we find mish mashes of themes and explanations of differing combinations of ideas about the afterlife, which in early Christianity were being further expounded and growing with the Enoch literature, not to mention the Dead Sea Scrolls. Soteriology was never settled. And it was never sedentary, but always developed, changed, and expanded through time.

The very invention of hell as a late comer to the theological field is proof. There was no hell in ancient Judaism of the Old Testament era, but only Sheol, which in some respects was similar to the Greek Hades. They were not equivalent however. So, we get to wonder were early Christians already combining two different ideas about the afterlife? Was there an immediate existence after death and a future bodily resurrection? Are those the only two options? Who can tell? Paradise doesn't solve it, it just means "a garden" from the Persian etymology.

After Jesus is when the New Testament apocrypha literally outran the entire corpus of New Testament scripture writings. Canonical status is simply another man-made doctrine that holds no doctrinal value in relation to what men decided they liked and hence canonized, and what didn't suit their predilections of a pet doctrine when it wasn't supported, so the book was not canonized. It's all arbitrarily based on what one believed and what one didn't. And there has never in all of theological history been agreement on that!
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Gadianton »

Philo wrote:If we approach this historically, we find mish mashes of themes and explanations of differing combinations of ideas about the afterlife, which in early Christianity were being further expounded and growing with the Enoch literature, not to mention the Dead Sea Scrolls. Soteriology was never settled. And it was never sedentary, but always developed, changed, and expanded through time.
From back when I read about this kind of stuff, afterlife beliefs seem to range from you're dead, it's bad to be dead so maybe it's spooky, to maybe there's not really anything, to, well, if you were good maybe it was a good place and if bad, somewhere between neutral, nothing, or really bad; but not strictly politically motivated. A good Roman could still be in the good place. Niche factions might have made it more political but in general, the good were taken care of.

Jesus's message complicates things because perhaps there is too much social subtlety to quickly understand it as an outsider. If good people of any background had provisions for going to the good place, what was the motivation for Jesus to go around acting as if it's a moment of crisis?

Jesus' message actually muddies the waters substantially. The good part is that he questioned the status quo as a means for determining good and bad. Just because you had an easy prosperous life, it's too easy to condemn the thief as "bad" per se. In many situations, Jesus is subversive, he finds a diamond in the rough in the social outcasts most would consider "bad" and perhaps more than anything, this self-assurance of one's privilege is a big strike against assumptions that a well-integrated person within society is "good".

But where does this leave us to evaluate people in general? Pretty much nowhere. The bad part is that the message easily becomes political -- the thief who recognized his failures, okay, that's the diamond in the rough moment, but the scene is setup to put less of an emphasis on his redeemable qualities, and more on politically allying himself with Jesus. The other guy on the cross laughs it off and remains cynical, well, he gets nothing? Because he didn't feel bad about what he did that was wrong, or because his politics didn't change to follow Jesus? The prostitute Jesus saved from stoning didn't repent to him before Jesus stopped the punishers in their tracks with his words. He showed mercy before she showed a change of heart.

So why couldn't that work with the other guy? Maybe he was just having a really bad day. He could have been the guy who was saved if the scene were set up differently in order to emphasize some other presumed failure in the status quo. So what is meant by who gets saved or damned because extremely complicated as the context is the social failures of the time. Going after the lost sheep is really important, tying it all to narrow allegiance to a particular shepherd is distracting.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
Morley
God
Posts: 2659
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 6:17 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Morley »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:28 pm
Morley wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 1:57 pm
...“both terms (Hades and Sheol) described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness”.
At this source while reading I read:
The message of these texts is that everyone goes to sheʾol. Jacob will join Joseph in sheʾol, and Saul will join Samuel, but the wicked kings of Babylon and Egypt will be there as well. The mighty and the meek, righteous and wicked, all end up the same way. Death is the great equalizer.
https://www.thetorah.com/article/no-hea ... on.%20Prof.
Reading the surrounding material there seems to be a conversation among the Rabbi's on whether this is the grave or an actual location/place.

Second Temple Judaism developed this further with the help of Greek thought.

The ancient Greeks thought of Hades as being:
...a place of “moldering horror” where ordinary people — and even heroes — went after they died. This place was immersed in misty darkness and sequestered by the dreaded River Styx.
https://europe.factsanddetails.com/arti ... l?hl=en-US
My point is that the idea of an afterlife where the wicked and the righteous go after death has been around a long time and that LDS theology fleshed this doctrine out.

I, admittedly, am not a scholar of the ancient world. Just an interested bystander with curiosity.

I don't know what your background is but if you can shed more light on this subject, that might be a good topic for a new thread. Psuedo(Sp.?) Paul and others (Gadianton?) might be willing to jump in.

Responding in good faith but lacking in a through in depth knowledge...

Regards,
MG
Ha! In this post, it appears that you’re pretending to have answered my question, and that you’re also asking me to join in that pretense. I think I’m supposed to clap you on the back and give you an attaboy. Am I right? In that spirit of good will and comity, please ignore the parts below that I’ve written and crossed out.

Nothing in any of this suggests ancient Israelites or Greeks regarded Sheol or Hades as intermediate places before heaven. [your emphasis, not mine]

Nothing here points to where you got this preposterous idea. Really, you could have just reevaluated your argument, and admitted it—instead of lamely posting content you hadn’t read and then trying to convince everyone else that there was any substance to it.

Wow! Good job!
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

I actually wouldn’t mind discussing this in more depth, in spite of the ambiguity of the sources cited and the predetermined direction MG wants the discussion to go.

These are interesting questions to me: Was Sheol the grave? An underworld? Were the dead conscious? In my mind it doesn’t make sense that a person could be “alive dead” or whatever a soul does after you die. It seems like when you’re dead you’re dead, not just your body, but the “you” that ever was.

Where I lose interest is when the uncertainty becomes an opportunity to introduce Joseph as the guy who finally revealed the answer.

I imagine it went something like this: “Look here! I found a theological question with no consensus! Let’s ask Joseph!” Which turned in to a pay for play to achieve the highest levels.

The trouble is we’re talking about a guy who previously claimed to find buried treasure using a seer stone, without any documented success in finding it, no less. So why should anyone believe anything he says is authoritative when the subject changes from buried treasure to the revelation of God’s will?

Frankly, if the answer ultimately comes down to “Joseph received a revelation,” I’d prefer the commentator just acknowledge that at the beginning rather than dressing it up as a conclusion established by historical scholarship.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4580
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by I Have Questions »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 1:46 am
I actually wouldn’t mind discussing this in more depth, in spite of the ambiguity of the sources cited and the predetermined direction MG wants the discussion to go.

These are interesting questions to me: Was Sheol the grave? An underworld? Were the dead conscious? In my mind it doesn’t make sense that a person could be “alive dead” or whatever a soul does after you die. It seems like when you’re dead you’re dead, not just your body, but the “you” that ever was.

Where I lose interest is when the uncertainty becomes an opportunity to introduce Joseph as the guy who finally revealed the answer.

I imagine it went something like this: “Look here! I found a theological question with no consensus! Let’s ask Joseph!” Which turned in to a pay for play to achieve the highest levels.

The trouble is we’re talking about a guy who previously claimed to find buried treasure using a seer stone, without any documented success in finding it, no less. So why should anyone believe anything he says is authoritative when the subject changes from buried treasure to the revelation of God’s will?

Frankly, if the answer ultimately comes down to “Joseph received a revelation,” I’d prefer the commentator just acknowledge that at the beginning rather than dressing it up as a conclusion established by historical scholarship.
We are also talking about a guy who passed off plagiarising the KJV Bible (and other sources) as the “translating of an ancient record.”
Last edited by I Have Questions on Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:48 am, edited 1 time in total.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
Morley
God
Posts: 2659
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 6:17 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Morley »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 1:46 am
I actually wouldn’t mind discussing this in more depth, in spite of the ambiguity of the sources cited and the predetermined direction MG wants the discussion to go.
So would I. There have been some fascinating ideas brought up here. I've been more interested than I expected to be.

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 1:46 am
These are interesting questions to me: Was Sheol the grave? An underworld? Were the dead conscious? In my mind it doesn’t make sense that a person could be “alive dead” or whatever a soul does after you die. It seems like when you’re dead you’re dead, not just your body, but the “you” that ever was.

Where I lose interest is when the uncertainty becomes an opportunity to introduce Joseph as the guy who finally revealed the answer.

I imagine it went something like this: “Look here! I found a theological question with no consensus! Let’s ask Joseph!” Which turned in to a pay for play to achieve the highest levels.

The trouble is we’re talking about a guy who previously claimed to find buried treasure using a seer stone, without any documented success in finding it, no less. So why should anyone believe anything he says is authoritative when the subject changes from buried treasure to the revelation of God’s will?

Frankly, if the answer ultimately comes down to “Joseph received a revelation,” I’d prefer the commentator just acknowledge that at the beginning rather than dressing it up as a conclusion established by historical scholarship.
I would even like to read Mormonism's take on the matter. There are some ideas there that can and should be compelling. I just ask that you don't hand me a pig and tell me it's a princess--and then, when I object, insist that I should take her home and marry her.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

Morley wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 9:39 am
So would I. There have been some fascinating ideas brought up here. I've been more interested than I expected to be.
I’m still trying to understand this business of Jesus preaching to the dead. If the dead can hear preaching and make decisions, are they really dead? Are we talking about dead people or just mostly dead people?

Because if they’re only mostly dead, there’s still time to go through their pockets and look for loose change.

But seriously, doesn’t this make resurrection something other than a return from death? If everyone is carrying on with life in another location, what is being restored through resurrection?

Additionally, in Luke 16:26, Abraham describes a great gulf that prevents anyone from crossing. There's no mention of missionary work among the dead or movement between the two conditions. In fact, the rich man's request to warn his living brothers suggests that the time to change their situation is before death.

So how does that fit into Mormon thought?

Exploratory: there is an assumption being made about 1 Peter that the text doesn’t say. Peter says Christ went and preached to the spirits in prison, but he doesn’t specifically say Jesus descended into Sheol or Hades.

Could the preaching be understood as an announcement of Christ’s victory through his death and resurrection? Or could the reference to the dead involve people spiritually dead in their sins, rather than people carrying on living somewhere else?

Just thinking out loud.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4580
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by I Have Questions »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 1:33 pm
Morley wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 9:39 am
So would I. There have been some fascinating ideas brought up here. I've been more interested than I expected to be.
I’m still trying to understand this business of Jesus preaching to the dead. If the dead can hear preaching and make decisions, are they really dead? Are we talking about dead people or just mostly dead people?

Because if they’re only mostly dead, there’s still time to go through their pockets and look for loose change.

But seriously, doesn’t this make resurrection something other than a return from death? If everyone is carrying on with life in another location, what is being restored through resurrection?

Additionally, in Luke 16:26, Abraham describes a great gulf that prevents anyone from crossing. There's no mention of missionary work among the dead or movement between the two conditions. In fact, the rich man's request to warn his living brothers suggests that the time to change their situation is before death.

So how does that fit into Mormon thought?

Exploratory: there is an assumption being made about 1 Peter that the text doesn’t say. Peter says Christ went and preached to the spirits in prison, but he doesn’t specifically say Jesus descended into Sheol or Hades.

Could the preaching be understood as an announcement of Christ’s victory through his death and resurrection? Or could the reference to the dead involve people spiritually dead in their sins, rather than people carrying on living somewhere else?

Just thinking out loud.
I note that you are starting with the assumption that the writer of Peter (and other Bible scripture) was an authority on the topic on which they were opining. And that they wrote without personal bias or agenda. I see no reason to make that assumption, but I understand why you would put that part of the discussion to one side in order to discuss something they wrote as if it were authoritative. For all we know, the writer of Peter was just the Jacob Hansen of his day. It could all just be a fictional tale designed to have a swipe at what was happening in Rome at that time. I don’t see any reason to accept that the author knew anything more about the afterlife than you or or I.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Rivendale
God
Posts: 2030
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2021 5:21 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Rivendale »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 1:33 pm
Morley wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 9:39 am
So would I. There have been some fascinating ideas brought up here. I've been more interested than I expected to be.
I’m still trying to understand this business of Jesus preaching to the dead. If the dead can hear preaching and make decisions, are they really dead? Are we talking about dead people or just mostly dead people?

Because if they’re only mostly dead, there’s still time to go through their pockets and look for loose change.

But seriously, doesn’t this make resurrection something other than a return from death? If everyone is carrying on with life in another location, what is being restored through resurrection?

Additionally, in Luke 16:26, Abraham describes a great gulf that prevents anyone from crossing. There's no mention of missionary work among the dead or movement between the two conditions. In fact, the rich man's request to warn his living brothers suggests that the time to change their situation is before death.

So how does that fit into Mormon thought?

Exploratory: there is an assumption being made about 1 Peter that the text doesn’t say. Peter says Christ went and preached to the spirits in prison, but he doesn’t specifically say Jesus descended into Sheol or Hades.

Could the preaching be understood as an announcement of Christ’s victory through his death and resurrection? Or could the reference to the dead involve people spiritually dead in their sins, rather than people carrying on living somewhere else?

Just thinking out loud.
Great thoughts and ideas. I have always thought baptism for the dead and missionaries in heaven to be antithetical to the atonement and only adds to the problem of evil. A person accepting a Mormon baptism after death while only getting the lowest tier of heaven makes mortality worthless, especially if the life was filled with misery. And how long does this supposed veil of forgetfulness last? You can be sure if a non-believer wakes up in heaven and has his premortal memories awakened they sure as hell wouldn't reject a salvation offer even if it is in the world of smoothies. Do we ever recieve our premortal memories that would span the past eternities or is their really a memory wipe to avoid sad heaven? And what about another rebellion like Satan accomplished in the past? Is that disabled to?
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 03, 2026 1:33 pm
Just thinking out loud.
That must be nice to be allowed to do so without being accused of this or that. However, I am glad to see the discussion develop among those who are board certified. ;)

I would add something but...it would be unacceptable for any one of a number of reasons that have been mentioned recently. The discussion will be much more 'level headed' and absent of any obvious errors in logic and/or faulty and superficial/faulty reading of sources that everyone else has of course read, digested, and understood.

You can then write and express yourself in such away as to demonstrate the erududite understandings of board certified participants.

Carry on. I will now sit at the feet of masters as I learn doctrine and theology from qualified individuals with talents, abilities, and character traits beyond my own.

Regards,
Fibber, misogynist, dubious researcher being prone to outbursts, and the non board certified member who may be characterized by circular reasoning, dorkiness, arrogance, whataboutism, and sloppy thinking.

Lord, is it I? The board thinks so. I am a sinful man without merit. I accused someone else of being a liar when they were not. Forgive me.

As part of my repentance process I will heretofore withdraw myself from participation on this board at any time when I know that sooner or later I will be exposed...again...as the sinner that I am.

Amen. Can I hear a hallelujah!
Last edited by MG 2.0 on Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Post Reply