Joe's Ranch

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
Morley
God
Posts: 2659
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 6:17 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Morley »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 11:45 pm
Morley wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:33 pm
What are your sources?
The Hebrew Bible (Tanakh), The Septuagint (LXX), The Greek New Testament...for early sources developing the idea of Sheol and Hades. These were fleshed out during the Second Temple period in Apocryphal writings and Pseudepigrapha (1 Enoch, 4 Ezra, and Testament of Abraham). The Second Temple Judaism and early Christianity developed the concept of Sheol and Hades into a framework meaning an intermediate waiting state ahead of a final resurrection and judgement.

Second Temple Judaism and early Christianity further developed the concept into an intermediate waiting state ahead of a final resurrection and judgment.

https://zondervanacademic.com/blog/intermediate-state
https://www.monergism.com/intermediate-state
https://Bible.org/seriespage/2-intermediate-state
https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/afterlife
https://digitalcommons.andrews.edu/cgi/ ... ntext=pubs

Have I read all of these? Of course not. But as I did a search I was linked to these sources. As you know Google search now results in an AI response along with source material.

I think it is debatable, to say the least, that the thief on the cross went to Heaven and that's where Christ met him. What I've said earlier in response to drumdude doesn't seem to support that theory. What I have found fits much better with LDS theology of the Spirit World/Spirit Prison.

Regards,
MG
Maybe, rather than throwing up a bunch of links to stuff you’ve admittedly not read, you’ll point out the passages in those articles that support your claim?
Morley
God
Posts: 2659
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 6:17 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Morley »

Here’s your claim:
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:32 pm
The research I’ve done supports what I’ve said. Within the context of biblical studies and Judeo-Christian theology both Sheol (Hebrew) and Hades (Greek) primarily refer to an intermediate, post-mortal realm of the dead before a final judgment or resurrection.
You make it sound like this is the consensus (or at least a mainstream) opinion in what you’re calling ‘Judeo-Christian theology.’
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

Is calling someone a “dope” good for the gander now?
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

Morley wrote: ↑
Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:11 am
Here’s your claim:
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:32 pm
The research I’ve done supports what I’ve said. Within the context of biblical studies and Judeo-Christian theology both Sheol (Hebrew) and Hades (Greek) primarily refer to an intermediate, post-mortal realm of the dead before a final judgment or resurrection.
You make it sound like this is the consensus (or at least a mainstream) opinion in what you’re calling ‘Judeo-Christian theology.’
It’s not at all consensus. It’s mildly humorous when a Mormon plays the “don’t tell me what I believe” card but then reverse Unos that same play.
Morley
God
Posts: 2659
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 6:17 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Morley »

Morley wrote: ↑
Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:11 am
Here’s your claim:
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:32 pm
The research I’ve done supports what I’ve said. Within the context of biblical studies and Judeo-Christian theology both Sheol (Hebrew) and Hades (Greek) primarily refer to an intermediate, post-mortal realm of the dead before a final judgment or resurrection.
You make it sound like this is the consensus (or at least a mainstream) opinion in what you’re calling ‘Judeo-Christian theology.’
And here’s the original post, that started my objection.
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:04 pm
Another problem you might run into if you are sending the thief directly to heaven is that the ancient Israelites believed in Sheol, and the classical Greeks believed in Hades. Both terms [Hades and Sheol] described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness.
The bold is yours. You’re going to show evidence that “the ancient Israelites believed in Sheol, and the classical Greeks believed in Hades.” And that “both terms (Hades and Sheol) described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness”.

No one is debating whether or not early Christians or some factions of Second Temple Judaism considered these concepts.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:12 am
Is calling someone a “dope” good for the gander now?
If anyone deserved it at that particular time he did. First time I’ve used that word in a long time.

Regards,
MG
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Philo Sofee »

I sincerely do not understand the issue here regarding Sheol. There was no system in early Israelite religion where Sheol was concerned with moral rewards and punishments. Good people went there. Bad people went there. Kings, servants, the wealthy, and the poor all faced death.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

Morley makes a good point. Even in Jesus’ day, the Pharisees and Sadducees disagreed about the resurrection and what happens to the dead. The major factions of the time didn’t agree that there was a resurrection, let alone a holding area prior to resurrection.

So what is this consensus he is talking about?

Even if they did agree, how would any of that negate a promise by Jesus that the thief be with Him in paradise that day?
User avatar
Gabriel
Priest
Posts: 293
Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2021 10:20 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Gabriel »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 11:45 pm

I think it is debatable, to say the least, that the thief on the cross went to Heaven and that's where Christ met him. What I've said earlier in response to drumdude doesn't seem to support that theory. What I have found fits much better with LDS theology of the Spirit World/Spirit Prison.

Regards,
MG
The Former-day Saints are, more or less, in agreement with you on this one.
AMBROSE. A most remarkable example is here given of seeking after conversion, seeing that pardon is so speedily granted to the thief. The Lord quickly pardons, because the thief is quickly converted. And grace is more abundant than prayer; for the Lord ever gives more than He is asked for. The thief asked that He should remember him, but our Lord answers, Verily I say unto thee, This day shall thou be with me in Paradise. To be with Christ is life, and where Christ is, there is His kingdom.

CHRYSOSTOM. Here then might one see the Saviour between the thieves weighing in the scales of justice faith, and unbelief. The devil cast Adam out of Paradise. Christ brought the thief into Paradise before the whole world, before the Apostles. By a mere word and by faith alone he entered into Paradise, that no one after his sins might despair of entrance. Mark the rapid change, from the cross to heaven, from condemnation to Paradise, that you may know that the Lord did it all, not with regard to the thief’s good intention, but His own mercy.

But if the reward of the good has already taken place, surely a resurrection will be superfluous. For if He introduced the thief into Paradise while his body remained in corruption without, it is clear there is no resurrection of the body. Such are the words of some, But shall the flesh which has partaken of the toil be deprived of the reward? Hear Paul speaking, Then must this corruptible put on incorruption. (1 Cor. 15:53.) But if the Lord promised the kingdom of heaven, but introduced the thief into Paradise, He does not yet recompense him the reward. But they say, Under the name of Paradise He signified the kingdom of heaven, using a well-known name in addressing a thief who knew nothing of difficult teaching. Now some do not read it, This day shall thou be with me in Paradise, but thus, I say unto thee on this day, and then follows, thou shalt be with me in Paradise. But we will add a still more obvious solution. For physicians when they see a man in a desperate state, say, He is already dead. So also the thief, since he no longer fears his falling back to perdition, is said to have entered Paradise.

THEOPHYLACT This however is more true than all, that although they have not obtained all the promises, I mean, the thief and the other saints in order that without us they might not be made perfect, (Heb. 11:40.) they are notwithstanding in the kingdom of heaven and Paradise.

GREGORY OF NYSSA. Here again, we must examine how the thief should be thought worthy of Paradise, seeing that a flaming sword prevents the entrance of the saints. But observe that the word of God describes it as turning about, so as it should obstruct the unworthy, but open a free entrance to life to the worthy.

GREGORY. (Mor. 12. c. 9.) Or that flaming sword is said to be turning, because that He knew the time would come when it must be removed; when He in truth should come, who by the mystery of His incarnation was to open to us the way of Paradise.

AMBROSE. But it must also be explained how the others, that is, Matthew and Mark, introduced two thieves reviling, while Luke, one reviling, the other resisting him. Perhaps this other at first reviled, but was suddenly converted. It may also have been spoken of one, but in the plural number; as in the Hebrews, They wandered in goat-skins, and they were sawn asunder; (Heb. 11:37.) whereas Elijah alone is related to have had a goat-skin, and Isaiah to have been sawn asunder. But mystically, the two thieves represent the two sinful people who were to be crucified by baptism with Christ, (Rom. 6:3.) whose disagreement likewise represents the difference of believers.

BEDE. For as many of us as were baptized in Christ Jesus, were baptized in His death; but we are washed by baptism, seeing we were sinners. But some, in that they praise God suffering in the flesh, are crowned; others, in that they refuse to have the faith or works of baptism, are deprived of the gift which they have received.

From the Catena Aurea by St. Thomas Aquinas: Luke Chapter 23
https://www.ecatholic2000.com/catena/untitled-84.shtml
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Philo Sofee »

Limnor:
So what is this consensus he is talking about?
I take it this refers to MG2.0? Apparently there is a consensus about something in early Christianity concerning Sheol or Hades or something? This gets into the history of religious ideas, a very fun topic to explore because it trashes testimonies pretty speedily if you aren't careful.
Post Reply