Limnor wrote: ↑Fri Oct 16, 2026 11:49 pm
-Unfortunately, there’s a 1976 BYU dissertation documenting it, and Oaks said it never happened under his administration.
Establish how broad the practice was across the university or what Oaks personally knew. Would a university president ordinarily be informed about every graduate-student dissertation? The study took place in a basement. D. Eugene Thorne obviously knew about it as did McBride. How far did the outreach/information from the study go out of the Psychology Department to other areas of the university, including administration?
Limnor wrote: ↑Fri Oct 16, 2026 11:49 pm
[Did] every other university had already discontinued the practice.
I think the information provided shows enough data to surmise, reasonably, that BYU was not alone at this time participating in this clinical practice. And that when the change was made to the DSM, BYU followed suit with other universities in discontinuing the clinical practice that up to a certain point had been accepted science.
I've made that fairly clear for those that want to go back and read what I've already said. It was a sad time in the history of universities. BYU played part in the mistaken therapy.
I think you would have to show through documentary evidence that Oaks was aware of what exactly was going on. And if he was, as an administrator familiar with the practices of other universities and 'accepted science', it is questionable as to whether he would have interfered anyway.
Regards,
MG