New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by drumdude »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:06 pm
drumdude wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 8:36 pm
As someone who still respects Christianity as a whole, I find it troubling that Mormonism drives people straight out of religion entirely.

In large part it’s because there is minimal room within Mormonism for reasonable nuanced belief. You’re constantly subject to lectures about fictional history, lectures about anti-LGBT morality, and subject to interrogations of your loyalty to the organization.

I don’t blame former Mormons for throwing away religion entirely but there is a whole other world of more tolerant religions out there that don’t ask you to leave your brain at the door.
Hi drumdude, I would push back on the idea that there is not room for "reasonable nuanced belief".

Nuance: A slight difference that changes how something is understood.

I think this is going to come naturally as one lives in the world with eyes wide open. Granted, not everyone lives that way. And that's perfectly OK.

I wonder how you might define "reasonable" within the context you are using it?

Regards,
MG
In my opinion it’s unreasonable to believe that Hebrews sailed to the Americas. It’s fine that some Mormons believe it, but if you are trying to be Mormon and take the science seriously you’re going to have a hard time.

I would love for there to be room in the church for doubt about the historicity of the Book of Mormon.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by MG 2.0 »

Doctor CamNC4Me wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:35 pm
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:06 pm
Hi drumdude, I would push back on the idea that there is not room for "reasonable nuanced belief".

Nuance: A slight difference that changes how something is understood.

I think this is going to come naturally as one lives in the world with eyes wide open. Granted, not everyone lives that way. And that's perfectly OK.

I wonder how you might define "reasonable" within the context you are using it?

Regards,MG
Do you ever, like, look at your thumb and think that all the atoms that make up your thumb could be mini universes? I like, sometimes I like look real close at my thumb and think I can kind of see all those little universes, you know? What if we’re like, you know, someone else’s mini universe, right? Like that’s the truth. Like, we’re all just universes being created and being destroyed and I think we’re just in someone’s thumb or something.
That is indeed profound. You may have hit on a deeper truth.
Kishkumen wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:43 pm
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 6:34 pm
It's a fine line They're walking, that's for sure. I think They may see the message of the church as being one that will appeal more to the humble/meek of the earth. Even intellectuals can find a certain sense of humility. ;)
I find it kind of humorous to watch LDS folk defending the Church from the position of assuming that intellectuals are proud, while others are meek and humble. I think it is meek and humble to follow the evidence instead of my assumptions, and for that reason I find it hard to do, even though that is the task I have set myself. Very often it is the allegedly meek and humble folk, or those who see themselves as such, who would rather proudly stick to their assumptions about lots of things.
Although, granted, I would think it may be more difficult. One might say that it is a cross that some have to bear in this life along with crosses of other types that others may have to bear.
Or maybe pride is a cross everyone, including LDS leaders and LDS apologists, has to bear in different ways.
It does go both ways, I'm sure.
drumdude wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 8:08 pm
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:06 pm
Hi drumdude, I would push back on the idea that there is not room for "reasonable nuanced belief".

Nuance: A slight difference that changes how something is understood.

I think this is going to come naturally as one lives in the world with eyes wide open. Granted, not everyone lives that way. And that's perfectly OK.

I wonder how you might define "reasonable" within the context you are using it?

Regards,
MG
In my opinion it’s unreasonable to believe that Hebrews sailed to the Americas. It’s fine that some Mormons believe it, but if you are trying to be Mormon and take the science seriously you’re going to have a hard time.

I would love for there to be room in the church for doubt about the historicity of the Book of Mormon.
I think there is. Reasonable and nuanced belief is not a crime. Especially when all is not known and/or understood. Granted, if you were to attend and LDS Priesthood Quorum meeting and bring up that particular topic, as a negative, it might not be seen as "edifying".

Gospel living and faith in Jesus Christ are most often the flavor(s) of the day when attending church. As it should be, wouldn't you think?

Regards,
MG
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Limnor »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 6:58 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Thu Oct 08, 2026 2:52 am
On the resurrection, sure, there are alternative explanations. Maybe it was fabricated, or Jesus survived the crucifixion, or someone else was substituted for him, as suggested by some Muslim thought. I acknowledge the whole thing falls apart if there was no resurrection.
Yes it does. If you were a bookie, what would you say the odds were that He was?

Regards,
MG
I don’t approach it like a bookie, MG. That doesn’t mean a person can’t acknowledge that there are other explanations. There are other explanations.

I think a person either believes Jesus was resurrected or They don’t. And I do. I honestly don't understand what value assigning betting odds to it might bring.
Kishkumen wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:43 pm
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 6:34 pm
It's a fine line They're walking, that's for sure. I think They may see the message of the church as being one that will appeal more to the humble/meek of the earth. Even intellectuals can find a certain sense of humility. ;)
I find it kind of humorous to watch LDS folk defending the Church from the position of assuming that intellectuals are proud, while others are meek and humble. I think it is meek and humble to follow the evidence instead of my assumptions, and for that reason I find it hard to do, even though that is the task I have set myself. Very often it is the allegedly meek and humble folk, or those who see themselves as such, who would rather proudly stick to their assumptions about lots of things.
Although, granted, I would think it may be more difficult. One might say that it is a cross that some have to bear in this life along with crosses of other types that others may have to bear.
Or maybe pride is a cross everyone, including LDS leaders and LDS apologists, has to bear in different ways.
I agree and don’t see why intellectual curiosity should be considered a cross to bear. Maybe it’s a question of definition. I don’t see how humility would require someone to stop asking questions or examining claims. In fact, recognizing that we might be wrong seems to me an important part of intellectual humility.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by MG 2.0 »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 9:22 pm
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 6:58 pm
Yes it does. If you were a bookie, what would you say the odds were that He was?

Regards,
MG
I don’t approach it like a bookie, MG. That doesn’t mean a person can’t acknowledge that there are other explanations. There are other explanations.

I think a person either believes Jesus was resurrected or They don’t. And I do. I honestly don't understand what value assigning betting odds to it might bring.
Earlier you said, "I acknowledge the whole thing falls apart if there was no resurrection."

I interpreted you saying this as a statement of fact, and objective truth. Sure, we can believe or not believe that the resurrection of Christ did in actuality (an objective truth) occurred. That doesn't mean that it did. We are speaking hypothetically...unless you have the objective proof that Jesus died and was resurrected on the third day. I also believe that He did.

So when I asked you "what are the odds?", I'm speaking of the odds that objectively Christ resurrected from the dead.

We can have faith and even use reason to suppose that He did, but we can't as a matter of fact prove anything, can we? I'm not trying to cause or precipitate any kind of a firefight. I'm asking a rather simple question. What are the odds? You think/know it's a black and white answer? Objectively?

Or do you simply believe?
Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 9:26 pm
Kishkumen wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:43 pm
I find it kind of humorous to watch LDS folk defending the Church from the position of assuming that intellectuals are proud, while others are meek and humble. I think it is meek and humble to follow the evidence instead of my assumptions, and for that reason I find it hard to do, even though that is the task I have set myself. Very often it is the allegedly meek and humble folk, or those who see themselves as such, who would rather proudly stick to their assumptions about lots of things.

Or maybe pride is a cross everyone, including LDS leaders and LDS apologists, has to bear in different ways.
I agree and don’t see why intellectual curiosity should be considered a cross to bear. Maybe it’s a question of definition. I don’t see how humility would require someone to stop asking questions or examining claims. In fact, recognizing that we might be wrong seems to me an important part of intellectual humility.
Intellectual curiosity is being human. For some humans, but not all. In and of itself, intellectual curiosity is not a sin. Not even.

Of course, we ALL ought to be aware of the possibility that we are wrong. That is humility. With the caveat that we can be pretty sure, for ourselves (and no one else), that we are more right on some things than wrong. That's also being human. ;)

None of us wants to think that we're stupid, right? :lol:

I think we run into problems when we seemingly judge others as having to ALWAYS be right...say religious leaders/sages/prophets. They are human too. :) They are having a mortal experience along with the rest of us.

I, for one, do not move about in the world thinking that other people are without fault. But I do think some people are more perfect/advanced than others in different respects.

Without intellectual curiosity, at least for me, the world would be a somewhat dull place to hang out day after day. But I do try and remain humble in the fact that there may be Superior Being/Entity that knows a heck of a lot more than I do. And I would hope that this Superior Being would not be leaving humanity totally helpless and wandering in complete darkness...even at noon day.

But sure, I suppose we can figure it all our for ourselves. How's that been working out so far on a historical/global/historical scale?

Regards,
MG
User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3957
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

Fibber wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 10:09 pm
Intellectual curiosity is being human. For some humans, but not all. In and of itself, intellectual curiosity is not a sin. Not even.

Of course, we ALL ought to be aware of the possibility that we are wrong. That is humility. With the caveat that we can be pretty sure, for ourselves (and no one else), that we are more right on some things than wrong. That's also being human. ;)

None of us wants to think that we're stupid, right? :lol:

I think we run into problems when we seemingly judge others as having to ALWAYS be right...say religious leaders/sages/prophets. They are human too. :) They are having a mortal experience along with the rest of us.

I, for one, do not move about in the world thinking that other people are without fault. But I do think some people are more perfect/advanced than others in different respects.

Without intellectual curiosity, at least for me, the world would be a somewhat dull place to hang out day after day. But I do try and remain humble in the fact that there may be Superior Being/Entity that knows a heck of a lot more than I do. And I would hope that this Superior Being would not be leaving humanity totally helpless and wandering in complete darkness...even at noon day.

But sure, I suppose we can figure it all our for ourselves. How's that been working out so far on a historical/global/historical scale?

Regards,
MG (MOD NOTE: original content/names within quoted posts should remain unchanged. -c-)
This comment reads like someone smoked weed behind the school gym once in 2004 and has spent the last two decades with the profound realization that because thinking is hard, he might as well just trust old men that believe They are prophets and call it humility. Easily the dumbest thing posted on this board in the last 15 years. Truly some stellar missionary work, Fibber.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by MG 2.0 »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 10:25 pm
Fibber wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 10:09 pm
Intellectual curiosity is being human. For some humans, but not all. In and of itself, intellectual curiosity is not a sin. Not even.

Of course, we ALL ought to be aware of the possibility that we are wrong. That is humility. With the caveat that we can be pretty sure, for ourselves (and no one else), that we are more right on some things than wrong. That's also being human. ;)

None of us wants to think that we're stupid, right? :lol:

I think we run into problems when we seemingly judge others as having to ALWAYS be right...say religious leaders/sages/prophets. They are human too. :) They are having a mortal experience along with the rest of us.

I, for one, do not move about in the world thinking that other people are without fault. But I do think some people are more perfect/advanced than others in different respects.

Without intellectual curiosity, at least for me, the world would be a somewhat dull place to hang out day after day. But I do try and remain humble in the fact that there may be Superior Being/Entity that knows a heck of a lot more than I do. And I would hope that this Superior Being would not be leaving humanity totally helpless and wandering in complete darkness...even at noon day.

But sure, I suppose we can figure it all our for ourselves. How's that been working out so far on a historical/global/historical scale?

Regards,
MG (MOD NOTE: original content/names within quoted posts should remain unchanged. -c-)
This comment reads like someone smoked weed behind the school gym once in 2004 and has spent the last two decades with the profound realization that because thinking is hard, he might as well just trust old men that believe They are prophets and call it humility. Easily the dumbest thing posted on this board in the last 15 years. Truly some stellar missionary work, Fibber.
Thank you so much! (Oh, and it was 1971...and more than once :lol: )

Thinking deeply is hard for some, isn't it?

Regards,
MG
User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3957
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

Fibber wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 10:33 pm
Thinking deeply is hard for some, isn't it?
Regards,
MG (MOD NOTE: original content/names within quoted posts should remain unchanged. -c-)
So it would seem. :lol:
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Limnor »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 9:55 pm
So when I asked you "what are the odds?", I'm speaking of the odds that objectively Christ resurrected from the dead.

We can have faith and even use reason to suppose that He did, but we can't as a matter of fact prove anything, can we? I'm not trying to cause or precipitate any kind of a firefight. I'm asking a rather simple question. What are the odds? You think/know it's a black and white answer? Objectively?

Or do you simply believe?
Maybe not a firefight but it’s kind of an “odd” question, MG. Odds? I mean how do you assign odds to a historical event? Are you trolling me with some sort of Sorites thing here?

I believe Jesus was resurrected. That’s about it, put simply.

But I’ll tell you what. Maybe we can pluck apart what you are trying to say. You may be asking “did it actually happen”? That's one thing. “Do I believe it happened?” is a second. “Does Christianity depend on it happening” is a third.

So:

1) Did it actually happen? I don’t know. Maybe 50/50 I guess? I don’t know how to quantify a historical event in terms of odds. I guess you’d have to weigh the evidence. Is that what you mean?
2) Do I believe it happened? Yes.
3) Does Christianity depend on it? Yes.
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 10:09 pm
I think we run into problems when we seemingly judge others as having to ALWAYS be right...say religious leaders/sages/prophets. They are human too. :) They are having a mortal experience along with the rest of us.
If the fallibility of prophets is a reason to extend them grace, the same fallibility is a reason to scrutinize their claims. How do you identify their mistakes from real revelation?
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by MG 2.0 »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 11:26 pm
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 9:55 pm
So when I asked you "what are the odds?", I'm speaking of the odds that objectively Christ resurrected from the dead.

We can have faith and even use reason to suppose that He did, but we can't as a matter of fact prove anything, can we? I'm not trying to cause or precipitate any kind of a firefight. I'm asking a rather simple question. What are the odds? You think/know it's a black and white answer? Objectively?

Or do you simply believe?
Maybe not a firefight but it’s kind of an “odd” question, MG. Odds? I mean how do you assign odds to a historical event? Are you trolling me with some sort of Sorites thing here?

I believe Jesus was resurrected. That’s about it, put simply.

But I’ll tell you what. Maybe we can pluck apart what you are trying to say. You may be asking “did it actually happen”? that's one thing. “Do I believe it happened?” is a second. “Does Christianity depend on it happening” is a third.

So:

1) Did it actually happen? I don’t know. Maybe 50/50 I guess? I don’t know how to quantify a historical event in terms of odds. I guess you’d have to weigh the evidence. Is that what you mean?
2) Do I believe it happened? Yes.
3) Does Christianity depend on it? Yes.
There you go. That wasn’t so hard now, was it? I’d go more than 50/50. Each person, of course, will have their own knobs to turn and fine tune to reach “a guess”. We don’t necessarily have to agree on the odds in regard to the literal/objective resurrection of Jesus.

Believing gets believers on the same page. And that’s a good place to start, wouldn’t you agree?
Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 11:35 pm
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 10:09 pm
I think we run into problems when we seemingly judge others as having to ALWAYS be right...say religious leaders/sages/prophets. They are human too. :) They are having a mortal experience along with the rest of us.
If the fallibility of prophets is a reason to extend them grace, the same fallibility is a reason to scrutinize their claims. How do you identify their mistakes from real revelation?
At times that can be difficult. They should be scrutinized. Over time I’ve come down on the grace side. And that can look different from time to time and situation to situation. When I play the odds I am prone to give them the benefit of a doubt, over all, but not always in specificity. Play by play action as we’d say in the sports world.

Regards,
MG
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS

Post by Limnor »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 11:55 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 11:26 pm
Maybe not a firefight but it’s kind of an “odd” question, MG. Odds? I mean how do you assign odds to a historical event? Are you trolling me with some sort of Sorites thing here?

I believe Jesus was resurrected. That’s about it, put simply.

But I’ll tell you what. Maybe we can pluck apart what you are trying to say. You may be asking “did it actually happen”? that's one thing. “Do I believe it happened?” is a second. “Does Christianity depend on it happening” is a third.

So:

1) Did it actually happen? I don’t know. Maybe 50/50 I guess? I don’t know how to quantify a historical event in terms of odds. I guess you’d have to weigh the evidence. Is that what you mean?
2) Do I believe it happened? Yes.
3) Does Christianity depend on it? Yes.
There you go. That wasn’t so hard now, was it? I’d go more than 50/50. Each person, of course, will have their own knobs to turn and fine tune to reach “a guess”. We don’t necessarily have to agree on the odds in regard to the literal/objective resurrection of Jesus.

Believing gets believers on the same page. And that’s a good place to start, wouldn’t you agree?

Regards,
MG
I don’t appreciate the “that wasn’t so hard” remark. I’m perfectly capable of explaining what I believe without being guided toward some predetermined conclusion.

As for getting believers on the same page, I’m not sure we are. We may both agree that Jesus was resurrected, but I suspect we have rather different understandings of what that resurrection means.

If you have a point you’re trying to make, I’d prefer you just make it. This is part of the reason I don’t trust you.
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Sat Oct 10, 2026 12:02 am
Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 09, 2026 11:35 pm
If the fallibility of prophets is a reason to extend them grace, the same fallibility is a reason to scrutinize their claims. How do you identify their mistakes from real revelation?
At times that can be difficult. They should be scrutinized. Over time I’ve come down on the grace side. And that can look different from time to time and situation to situation. When I play the odds I am prone to give them the benefit of a doubt, over all, but not always in specificity. Play by play action as we’d say in the sports world.

Regards,
MG
Forgiving someone's mistakes is different from continuing to accept their claims of authority to speak in Gods name.

You can extend grace to someone who deceived you without continuing to believe what They told you. Forgiveness is one thing. Continued trust after being deceived is another.

If someone fooled me into believing he was a prophet, why would I continue giving him the benefit of the doubt about his prophetic claims?

So since we’re playing the odds, where do you put the odds that Joseph sincerely believed his claims from the odds that those claims were actually true? I think Vogel said something like Joseph actually believed his claims. I put it at zero.
Post Reply