New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
- Everybody Wang Chung
- God
- Posts: 3957
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
Blake Ostler is an intellectual.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."
Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
-
Marcus
- God
- Posts: 8297
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
I would tend to think so too. Why would coming to Christ require turning control of your mind over to another human?Kish wrote:...I appreciate your candor regarding the lack of resources for intellectuals in the LDS Church. I understand that the LDS Church sees itself as a vehicle to lead its members to Christ. I tend to think that they would not have to sacrifice that mission by remembering the poor folks who like to think more than the average person.mg wrote: ...Although I would say, that the church sees itself as a vehicle to lead its members to Christ. They may see open discussion which might produce doubt/questions to be counterproductive to that endeavor.
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
Sure but this is just how I view it and don’t consider myself an authoritative spokesperson, it’s just where I’ve landed. The image that comes closest to what I mean is Jesus’ vine and branches analogy in John 15. The branch doesn’t produces its own fruit. It remains connected to the vine, and the life of the vine produces fruit through it. So when I say “Christ in you,” I think I mean something like that.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Wed Oct 07, 2026 2:27 amCan you expand on that a little? I’m interested in understanding what you think that means, in practice, and also how you see Christ historically.Limnor wrote: ↑Wed Oct 07, 2026 2:22 amI’ve mostly abandoned organized religion for the same reasons you’re describing. What I haven’t abandoned is the idea that Christ can actually be present in a person. That “Christ in you” is more than a religious affiliation. That’s really the part I still believe.
Practically, I think it works something like this: God loves and forgives you, and believing that love and forgiveness changes you. You then extend that same love and forgiveness to others. That, to me, is the fruit, the life of Christ working itself outward through you.
Historically, I believe Jesus was a real first-century Jewish man who was crucified and resurrected.
-
I Have Questions
- God
- Posts: 4582
- Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
Thanks for explaining. I think you’re applying “God” like Texas Sharpshooter draws a target. If an atheist shows love and forgiveness to others, simply because they know that’s the right thing to do psychologically for them, and they feel improved as a result, it doesn’t automatically equate to a God’s influence. Unless you have pre determined that you want it to. You could equally say, with the same legitimacy, that it was Apollo or Nature or Thetans behind it. Have you “found” God in your adult years in some way, or was God imprinted on you from an early age?Limnor wrote: ↑Wed Oct 07, 2026 11:47 pmSure but this is just how I view it and don’t consider myself an authoritative spokesperson, it’s just where I’ve landed. The image that comes closest to what I mean is Jesus’ vine and branches analogy in John 15. The branch doesn’t produces its own fruit. It remains connected to the vine, and the life of the vine produces fruit through it. So when I say “Christ in you,” I think I mean something like that.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Wed Oct 07, 2026 2:27 amCan you expand on that a little? I’m interested in understanding what you think that means, in practice, and also how you see Christ historically.
Practically, I think it works something like this: God loves and forgives you, and believing that love and forgiveness changes you. You then extend that same love and forgiveness to others. That, to me, is the fruit, the life of Christ working itself outward through you.
Historically, I believe Jesus was a real first-century Jewish man who was crucified and resurrected.
I’m not trying to be offensively provocative. But you know me well enough now to know that my default setting is to ask challenging questions as a means of getting to the real foundation of any discussion.
In terms of Jesus. I also think he was a historical figure. There seems to be sufficient objective evidence that a person like that in that time and place existed. But I’m not buying the walking on water etc and I think it is far more likely that he survived a crucifixion than actually died and came back to life - although he may well have portrayed himself as coming back to life to take advantage of that situation. Even people today are pronounced dead who then seemingly come back to life. Of course, they were never actually dead in the first place.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
I don’t take your questions as offensive at all. I think they’re fair. I’m really just describing how I understand my own relationship with God, rather than trying to offer proof of his existence. I acknowledge that if I’d grown up in Saudi Arabia, or in Utah, I might believe something completely different. And sure, I can recognize the Texas sharpshooter fallacy as a possible criticism if I were looking for evidence to justify a belief I’d already settled on. I can even see that playing out in looking for Old Testament prophecies fulfilled in Jesus. It’s just that I don’t attend church, pay tithes, or have much invested in defending a particular religious system. That doesn’t mean I’m immune to bias, of course. I think where I’ve landed is simply the result of an honest examination of myself and what I believe.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Thu Oct 08, 2026 12:29 amThanks for explaining. I think you’re applying “God” like Texas Sharpshooter draws a target. If an atheist shows love and forgiveness to others, simply because they know that’s the right thing to do psychologically for them, and they feel improved as a result, it doesn’t automatically equate to a God’s influence. Unless you have pre determined that you want it to. You could equally say, with the same legitimacy, that it was Apollo or Nature or Thetans behind it. Have you “found” God in your adult years in some way, or was God imprinted on you from an early age?
I’m not trying to be offensively provocative. But you know me well enough now to know that my default setting is to ask challenging questions as a means of getting to the real foundation of any discussion.
In terms of Jesus. I also think he was a historical figure. There seems to be sufficient objective evidence that a person like that in that time and place existed. But I’m not buying the walking on water etc and I think it is far more likely that he survived a crucifixion than actually died and came back to life - although he may well have portrayed himself as coming back to life to take advantage of that situation. Even people today are pronounced dead who then seemingly come back to life. Of course, they were never actually dead in the first place.
I don’t think Christians have a monopoly on love, forgiveness, or goodness. And I wouldn’t suggest that an atheist who demonstrates those things is secretly practicing Christianity. There may be other systems out there that speak to the human condition but I agree with the idea that the world has “fallen” and is in need of redemption.
As for whether God was imprinted on me from childhood, my experience was different from what I understand to be typical in LDS families. My family wasn’t particularly religious, although I was baptized Catholic as an infant. My parents divorced when I was nine, and I remember my mother taking solace in the church at that time. I also remember looking at the large crucifix behind the altar and feeling horrified and afraid.
I had something of a “found” moment when I was about 24. At the time I probably would have described it as having “caught fire.” I went around knocking on doors and probably mostly just irritated people.
I’ve explained elsewhere on the board that I’ve had experiences that brought me face to face with death, having even delivered it, and those experiences led me to critically examine myself and who it is I claim to be. I’ve landed at the understanding of Christ that I described upthread.
On the resurrection, sure, there are alternative explanations. Maybe it was fabricated, or Jesus survived the crucifixion, or someone else was substituted for him, as suggested by some Muslim thought. I acknowledge the whole thing falls apart if there was no resurrection.
- Kishkumen
- God
- Posts: 10503
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
- Location: Cassius University
- Contact:
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
Thank you for sharing, Limnor. After all this time wrestling with religious questions, I still think of myself as Christian for similar reasons. It is not a big part of my outward life in that I am not a very good Christian and do not go out testifying since my LDS mission, but my values are very much rooted in the life and ministry of Jesus. It is a personal thing, and not something that I put out there in comparative terms, denying the good that exists everywhere among the religious and non-religious. I asked myself how I wanted to be in the world, and that is where I landed.Limnor wrote: ↑Wed Oct 07, 2026 11:47 pmSure but this is just how I view it and don’t consider myself an authoritative spokesperson, it’s just where I’ve landed. The image that comes closest to what I mean is Jesus’ vine and branches analogy in John 15. The branch doesn’t produces its own fruit. It remains connected to the vine, and the life of the vine produces fruit through it. So when I say “Christ in you,” I think I mean something like that.
Practically, I think it works something like this: God loves and forgives you, and believing that love and forgiveness changes you. You then extend that same love and forgiveness to others. That, to me, is the fruit, the life of Christ working itself outward through you.
Historically, I believe Jesus was a real first-century Jewish man who was crucified and resurrected.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
Thanks Kish. To bring back a relevancy to Mormonism, something that bugs me is the idea that baptism by water by a man is the same baptism that Jesus spoke of. John the Baptist said Jesus himself would baptize with fire and the Holy Spirit. That’s what I find odd—it’s like they steal Jesus’ priesthood and act as though they can confer the Holy Spirit. I believe only God could do that. That approach grates against my refusal to allow an institution to claim authority that just doesn't belong to it.Kishkumen wrote: ↑Thu Oct 08, 2026 3:46 pmThank you for sharing, Limnor. After all this time wrestling with religious questions, I still think of myself as Christian for similar reasons. It is not a big part of my outward life in that I am not a very good Christian and do not go out testifying since my LDS mission, but my values are very much rooted in the life and ministry of Jesus. It is a personal thing, and not something that I put out there in comparative terms, denying the good that exists everywhere among the religious and non-religious. I asked myself how I wanted to be in the world, and that is where I landed.
I’d also add that, for me, the idea of following the example of Jesus focuses not so much on my producing works, but rather on His statements that it is the Father dwelling in him does the works, and He also tells his disciples that apart from him they can do nothing. So I think that’s another example of the vine and branches analogy.
It’s funny, because none of this is really my usual focus here. I originally came to this board to share a theory about how the Book of Mormon was composed, and that’s still where most of my interest lies. I didn’t intend to get into discussions about my own faith, but I also don’t mind examining it, and appreciate the opportunity to think through some of these questions with you and IHQ.
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
It's a fine line they're walking, that's for sure. I think they may see the message of the church as being one that will appeal more to the humble/meek of the earth. Even intellectuals can find a certain sense of humility.
Although, granted, I would think it may be more difficult. One might say that it is a cross that some have to bear in this life along with crosses of other types that others may have to bear.
One might ask whether faith/sacrifice was ever meant to be easy at all times and in all situations. And if not, why not? (and if so, does it defeat the purpose of having to exercise faith/sacrifice?)
Would the Romans allow for that to happen?I Have Questions wrote: ↑Thu Oct 08, 2026 12:29 amIn terms of Jesus...I think it is far more likely that he survived a crucifixion than actually died and came back to life...
It's seems highly unlikely He survived the actual process of crucifixion, doesn't it?I Have Questions wrote: ↑Thu Oct 08, 2026 12:29 am...although he may well have portrayed himself as coming back to life to take advantage of that situation.
Having been put to death by the same means the Romans used to kill Jesus?I Have Questions wrote: ↑Thu Oct 08, 2026 12:29 amEven people today are pronounced dead who then seemingly come back to life.
Yes it does. If you were a bookie, what would you say the odds were that He was?Limnor wrote: ↑Thu Oct 08, 2026 2:52 amOn the resurrection, sure, there are alternative explanations. Maybe it was fabricated, or Jesus survived the crucifixion, or someone else was substituted for him, as suggested by some Muslim thought. I acknowledge the whole thing falls apart if there was no resurrection.
Hi drumdude, I would push back on the idea that there is not room for "reasonable nuanced belief".drumdude wrote: ↑Sat Sep 26, 2026 8:36 pmAs someone who still respects Christianity as a whole, I find it troubling that Mormonism drives people straight out of religion entirely.
In large part it’s because there is minimal room within Mormonism for reasonable nuanced belief. You’re constantly subject to lectures about fictional history, lectures about anti-LGBT morality, and subject to interrogations of your loyalty to the organization.
I don’t blame former Mormons for throwing away religion entirely but there is a whole other world of more tolerant religions out there that don’t ask you to leave your brain at the door.
Nuance: A slight difference that changes how something is understood.
I think this is going to come naturally as one lives in the world with eyes wide open. Granted, not everyone lives that way. And that's perfectly OK.
I wonder how you might define "reasonable" within the context you are using it?
Regards,
MG
- Doctor CamNC4Me
- God
- Posts: 11198
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:04 am
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
Do you ever, like, look at your thumb and think that all the atoms that make up your thumb could be mini universes? I like, sometimes I like look real close at my thumb and think I can kind of see all those little universes, you know? What if we’re like, you know, someone else’s mini universe, right? Like that’s the truth. Like, we’re all just universes being created and being destroyed and I think we’re just in someone’s thumb or something.MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Fri Oct 09, 2026 7:06 pmHi drumdude, I would push back on the idea that there is not room for "reasonable nuanced belief".drumdude wrote: ↑Sat Sep 26, 2026 8:36 pmAs someone who still respects Christianity as a whole, I find it troubling that Mormonism drives people straight out of religion entirely.
In large part it’s because there is minimal room within Mormonism for reasonable nuanced belief. You’re constantly subject to lectures about fictional history, lectures about anti-LGBT morality, and subject to interrogations of your loyalty to the organization.
I don’t blame former Mormons for throwing away religion entirely but there is a whole other world of more tolerant religions out there that don’t ask you to leave your brain at the door.
Nuance: A slight difference that changes how something is understood.
I think this is going to come naturally as one lives in the world with eyes wide open. Granted, not everyone lives that way. And that's perfectly OK.
I wonder how you might define "reasonable" within the context you are using it?
Regards,
MG
That’s how retarded you sound, all the time.
Hiring a part-time news entertainment anchor as SecDef, what could go wrong?
- Kishkumen
- God
- Posts: 10503
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
- Location: Cassius University
- Contact:
Re: New Pew research shows LDS retention rate worsening for those raised LDS
Mormonism is rooted in Joseph Smith's interpretation of things, among which is the Bible. His interpretations can be interesting and sometimes puzzling. I prefer not to feel stuck with his view of things, but then to a certain extent I have been shaped by his religion for so long that it would be hard to divorce myself from it. To offer something in response to your question, I don't know what to make of anyone's attempts to institutionalize the portrait of Jesus in the New Testament. Everyone does it wrong to one degree or another, but communities form in response to some individual's or group's interpretation of Jesus' ministry and resurrection. I tend to feel that the individual's experience of the Divine and how that changes their life is the crucial thing, but communities will create procedures that mark belonging.Limnor wrote: ↑Fri Oct 09, 2026 2:44 amThanks Kish. To bring back a relevancy to Mormonism, something that bugs me is the idea that baptism by water by a man is the same baptism that Jesus spoke of. John the Baptist said Jesus himself would baptize with fire and the Holy Spirit. That’s what I find odd—it’s like they steal Jesus’ priesthood and act as though they can confer the Holy Spirit. I believe only God could do that. That approach grates against my refusal to allow an institution to claim authority that just doesn't belong to it.
That sounds more mystical, and I like it. For a long time, especially after reading the Didache and thinking about the influence of Dionysian religions on Christianity, I have found the vine metaphor very attractive and worthy of contemplation.I’d also add that, for me, the idea of following the example of Jesus focuses not so much on my producing works, but rather on His statements that it is the Father dwelling in him does the works, and He also tells his disciples that apart from him they can do nothing. So I think that’s another example of the vine and branches analogy.
Well, I am happy to see you discuss these things, too! Your Book of Mormon work is fascinating, and I like what you have to say about your faith as well.It’s funny, because none of this is really my usual focus here. I originally came to this board to share a theory about how the Book of Mormon was composed, and that’s still where most of my interest lies. I didn’t intend to get into discussions about my own faith, but I also don’t mind examining it, and appreciate the opportunity to think through some of these questions with you and IHQ.
I find it kind of humorous to watch LDS folk defending the Church from the position of assuming that intellectuals are proud, while others are meek and humble. I think it is meek and humble to follow the evidence instead of my assumptions, and for that reason I find it hard to do, even though that is the task I have set myself. Very often it is the allegedly meek and humble folk, or those who see themselves as such, who would rather proudly stick to their assumptions about lots of things.
Or maybe pride is a cross everyone, including LDS leaders and LDS apologists, has to bear in different ways.Although, granted, I would think it may be more difficult. One might say that it is a cross that some have to bear in this life along with crosses of other types that others may have to bear.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.