Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
Doctor Scratch
B.H. Roberts Chair of Mopologetic Studies
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Location: Cassius University

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Doctor Scratch »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 28, 2026 2:17 am
Gadianton wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:11 pm
A few observations about violence in Mormonism are also in order.
Thank you for this, Gad. I had been thinking the underlying idea was basically, “Well, it’s okay because the bad guys deserve it. They hardly qualify as real people.”

There’s a bit I wouldn’t mind exploring a bit further, however. Do you think apologists are actually trying to have it both ways: seeking a darker, grittier, morally serious reading of the book, while also retaining the Disney version, where the violence doesn’t require much moral thought because the good guys and bad guys are already sorted out for you?
I think there actually may be a bit more to it than that, and I think it's worth considering the fact that the observations about the unyieldingly "real" quality of profanity and sex and happening in the context of a discussion about why hardcore violence is permissible within a Mopologetic entertainment paradigm.

I wonder: have others read Pauline Kael's classic review of the film Taxi Driver? The movie, of course, is one of the greatest films of all time: a Martin Scorsese tour-de-force starring Robert De Niro as the deeply troubled loner, Travis Bickle: a character who refers to himself as "God's lonely man." Like the Mopologists, Bickle sees himself as defending something; for Bickle, it's the female characters, and for the Mopologists, it's the Church. Also like the Mopologists, Bickle has a peculiar relationship with sex. In her review, Kael writes that Bickle is "an ascetic not by choice but out of fear." The Mopologists have a Mickey Mouse-esque relationship to sexuality and nudity out of fear: they are afraid that if they cave in and look, then their eternal salvation might get taken away. In the movie, Bickle powerfully dislikes the sex workers that he sees as he's driving his taxicab at night, and he also seems uninterested in having actual sex, but he nonetheless routinely goes to the porno theaters in Manhattan. Perhaps it's similar to what Meurer proposed: Bickle doesn't see the porn films as "real," and so therefore, they are non-threatening in a way that actual sex *is*?

But Taxi Driver winds up being an extremely violent film. Bickle befriends a 12-year-old prostitute named Iris (played by Jodie Foster), and he eventually "goes rogue" and buys an arsenal of guns so that he can take out her pimp and the other "critics" who are corrupting her. I think Kael's interpretation of this climactic violence is especially insightful: "Violence is Travis’s only means of expressing himself. He has not been able to hurdle the barriers to being seen and felt. When he blasts through, it’s his only way of telling the city that he’s there. And given his ascetic loneliness, it’s the only real orgasm he can have."

So, clearly there are differences between the Mopologists and Travis Bickle, but I *do* think that their harebrained defense of "wholesome extreme violence" has some similarities to what Kael is describing. The typical Mopologist is *required* to live the life of an ascetic vis-a-vis sex and sexuality, and there can be no doubt that this feels unfair. I mean, these guys are "Judges over Israel," and yet they're not allowed to thumb through the swimsuit issue of Sports Illustrated? (It would have to be done in secret.) Is it a source of shame if they stare a little too long and hard at Jessica Rabbit? My point being: I think that the Mopologists enjoyment of this violent content winds up working in a similar way to Bickle's violence in Taxi Driver. Obviously, the Mopologists generally aren't lonely and isolated in the way that Travis is; instead, they operate more like a mob or a gang. But my point here, in any case, is that the silly defense of hardcore violence seems like a way of coping with the fact that they have a cartoonish view of sexuality and that they've traded their ability to behave like normal men in exchange for a system that charges them 10% of their income in the hopes of going to the evergreen pastures of Added Upon.
Last edited by Doctor Scratch on Mon Sep 28, 2026 4:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"If, while hoping that everybody else will be honest and so forth, I can personally prosper through unethical and immoral acts without being detected and without risk, why should I not?." --Daniel Peterson, 6/4/14
User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3957
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

Not surprisingly perhaps, it is men with aggressive tendencies and those who are low in empathy that have been found to like watching violence on screen.

It is relevant to know why some people enjoy watching violence, but it is even more important to find out whether exposure to violence in films and TV may actually promote violence in real life. There is some empirical evidence that this is the case.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog ... bad-for-us

Science keeps telling us that watching on-screen violence can turn people into real-life monsters, and honestly, that checks out if we look at the Proprietor. Studies show that folks with a natural taste for anger and aggression gravitate toward violent movies, which fits the Proprietor's personality like a straitjacket. After all, this is a man who has openly delighted in Angela Lansbury’s on-screen death in The Manchurian Candidate and proudly bragged about nearly physically assaulting Bill Maher at a restaurant, confronted Blair Hodges in a bookstore and told him to "go to hell," etc. The Proprietor's anger, aggression and temper are legendary.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4582
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by I Have Questions »

Doctor Scratch wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 4:00 pm
You have to wonder sometimes about the naïveté of the Mopologists:
Jamison Meurer wrote:In addition to Dr. Peterson's cogent point, most people watching a movie understand that the violence in it is fake. There is no way to fake nudity or profanity. Any examples of either in a movie is the real deal.
The Afore wrote:Excellent points. Thanks for making them.
This is exactly the kind of insidious message that Church Leaders consistently warn people about. Particularly youth. Watching violent films is NOT okay as far as the Church is concerned. And I would counsel anyone reading Meurer’s and Peterson’s justifications to see the sneaky enticement within them. It makes one wonder just how much attention these people pay to their Church Leaders counsel. That they would spread this type of harmful message is staggering.
For The Strength Of Youth
Seek that which uplifts, inspires, and invites the Spirit. As you make choices about what to watch, read, listen to, or participate in, think about how it makes you feel. Does it invite good thoughts? Stay away from anything that mocks sacred things or is immoral. Don’t participate in anything that dulls your judgment or sensitivity to the Spirit, such as violence, alcohol, and harmful drugs. Have the courage to turn off a video or game, walk out of a movie or dance, change your music, or turn away from anything that is not consistent with the Spirit.
I sincerely hope the words of these two numpties don’t reach the ears of the youth of the Church.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Limnor »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 28, 2026 2:11 pm
Limnor wrote:Do you think apologists are actually trying to have it both ways: seeking a darker, grittier, morally serious reading of the book, while also retaining the Disney version
Yes. In fact, the search for scholarly respectability, complexity, and for what is appealing to the vain imaginations of the world is entirely tied to their embarrassment and is optional. If they didn't need to endure the knowing smiles, they would completely embrace the Disney version without a second thought. So they don't try to reconcile these worlds, they put on a certain face to defend complexity. The perfect analog here is MG. How many hours has he invested in topics related to uncertainty and the problem of knowledge (without really grasping the subject matter) for no reason other than a defense for his utter certainty in his religious beliefs? Do you think he has any interest in those topics if the heat is off his religion?
This is just it—I really don’t know, because it’s not like a real conversation ever comes from it regarding these things. I can guess that the lack of actual discussion is due to uncertainty which results in the defenses being deployed, but the truth is it seems like I’m not allowed to know that there are doubts.

What do you mean by the “knowing smiles” reference?
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Limnor »

Doctor Scratch wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 28, 2026 4:07 pm
But my point here, in any case, is that the silly defense of hardcore violence seems like a way of coping with the fact that they have a cartoonish view of sexuality and that they've traded their ability to behave like normal men in exchange for a system that charges them 10% of their income in the hopes of going to the evergreen pastures of Added Upon.
There may be a historical precedent here. Joseph’s violence could be very real, so long as it was righteous violence. It could even be imaginary, as seen with the reports of scalping and disemboweling imaginary natives. But sex was confidential and dangerous, if caught. In that sense, violence could take a back seat in the hierarchy of morality.
User avatar
malkie
God
Posts: 2863
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:41 pm
Location: Ontario, Canada

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by malkie »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 2:32 pm
malkie wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 4:03 am
In my experience, folks here are fine with a PM pointing out minor issues, like a misplaced "[sic]", and may fix the error and sometimes even give the pointer-outer a nod in passing.
Having read some of Tom’s threads, it seems like he likes precision, and I was just helping out in a friendly way.

What’s a PM[sic]?
I sent you a PM - private message - I believe PM is a commonly understood internet expression. It's the modern equivalent of speaking to someone privately rather than in public, and may be regarded as more friendly than openly pointing out an issue.
You can help Ukraine by talking for an hour a week!! PM me, or check www.enginprogram.org for details.
Слава Україні!, 𝑺𝒍𝒂𝒗𝒂 𝑼𝒌𝒓𝒂𝒊𝒏𝒊!
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Gadianton »

Limnor wrote:What do you mean by the “knowing smiles” reference?
Imagine yourself as a Mormon scholar at an academic conference and you're an anthropologist or something like that. You're walking around the room feeling pretty important, like you're as good or better than anyone else there. You get pulled to the side by a colleague and have a chat, and in the course of the chat it's revealed that you're Mormon. That's when the smile comes. Your new friend isn't going to be rude, in fact, he'll probably lean in to the "good people" patronization. His great aunt or his former neighbors were Mormon and man, they were good people. Gullible as crap, but good people nevertheless. And imagine that, now he's met another one of these Normans -- wait, it's Mormons -- and this guy is an anthropologist? What are they putting in the water down there in Provo? Gold plates and Nephites? What a laugh!

As a Mormon scholar, you can feel your standing as an equal diminish behind that polite smile. This comes with a tinge of anger. That guy will stand before the Lord eventually and be punished for that smile. But it's just not good enough. You need revenge now. And really, the only turf that will satisfy without risk of jail is the intellectual domain, and so the intellectual complexity of the Book of Mormon in some way go beyond that guy's ability to grasp.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Kishkumen
God
Posts: 10504
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
Location: Cassius University
Contact:

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Kishkumen »

I think the big difference here is that very few people are ashamed to be seen watching "wholesome extreme violence," whereas they would feel embarrassed being seen watching sex. They watch plenty of sex or fantasize about sex even more than they watch the violence, but it is too embarrassing to be caught doing so--to be caught feeling aroused in public. So, they feel more comfortable pretending to be people who do not like watching or fantasizing about sex.

This is kinda like attitudes about PDA. Not everyone wants to be around people who can't control themselves sexually in public. Recently, I was visiting a museum when a couple that came in after me started making out throughout the tour. The museum was quiet, and you could hear them incessantly slobbering all over each other as they played grab ass. They were also very unattractive people. On the one hand, we can say that they are adults living in a free country, exercising their rights to do as they please. On the other hand, it was pretty nauseating.

Call me a prude: while I love sex and think it is healthy, I prefer that this healthy part of life be enjoyed out of the public eye, not out in public.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
User avatar
Dr LOD
Nursery
Posts: 31
Joined: Mon Nov 16, 2020 9:42 pm

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Dr LOD »

Thankfully, my parents taught me that morality was about much more than sex. Sex has its proper private context, sure, but cruelty, bloodshed, and learning to enjoy human suffering are moral questions too. In fact, the Church’s own youth guidance quoted above specifically warns against entertainment that dulls one’s sensitivity through violence.

So when Dan Peterson treats onscreen sex or nudity as uniquely “alluring” while being comparatively relaxed about graphic violence, he is showing us something about his own moral hierarchy. Maybe that hierarchy is culturally familiar, but it is hardly self-evident. How many onscreen murders, beatings, and dismemberments does it take before they become morally equivalent to one set of boobs?
Actual physician. Degree in genetics. Amateur Mormonologist. Pipe strictly decorative. Opinions frequently off-label and not evaluated by the FDA, the SCMC, or FAIR.
User avatar
Kishkumen
God
Posts: 10504
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
Location: Cassius University
Contact:

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Kishkumen »

Dr LOD wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 6:21 pm
Thankfully, my parents taught me that morality was about much more than sex. Sex has its proper private context, sure, but cruelty, bloodshed, and learning to enjoy human suffering are moral questions too. In fact, the Church’s own youth guidance quoted above specifically warns against entertainment that dulls one’s sensitivity through violence.

So when Dan Peterson treats onscreen sex or nudity as uniquely “alluring” while being comparatively relaxed about graphic violence, he is showing us something about his own moral hierarchy. Maybe that hierarchy is culturally familiar, but it is hardly self-evident. How many onscreen murders, beatings, and dismemberments does it take before they become morally equivalent to one set of boobs?
Good questions. I am speaking to the issue of what is commonplace in our culture, not to what the ideals should be. LDS culture will tend to track the larger culture, at least the Protestant side of it, and I don't expect it to behave in strikingly unique ways in this regard. In fact, for the most part, you can look at what the right-leaning Protestants are doing, and the Mormons are probably doing something similar. That starts with LDS leadership and goes all the way down to the average member. Even in cases where LDS leaders technically have quite a different position, the cultural tendencies hover in the same zone as those of conservative Protestants.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
Post Reply