Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by The Before »

Some interesting points here. I wonder if part of this is being located in the American West rather than something generated entirely by Mormon theology. Early Mormon culture matured in a nineteenth-century western environment in which vigilantism, militias, personal self-redress, armed conflict, and extralegal violence were hardly exotic. Utah wasn’t culturally sealed off from that world; in many respects it participated in it.

Mormonism then seems to have layered its own narratives onto that existing western vocabulary of violence: Nephite warfare, persecution in Missouri and Illinois, militias, vengeance rhetoric, blood atonement, apocalyptic destruction, etc. So perhaps what looks like a distinctively Mormon comfort with “righteous violence” is partly Mormon and partly Western.

The question I’d be interested in is whether that synthesis survived modernization. Modern Mormons obviously aren’t nineteenth-century frontierspeople, but the cultural distinction between bad violence and righteous/defensive violence may have deeper roots than the Book of Mormon alone. The same culture that objects strongly to profanity or sexuality can still experience the good guy blowing away the bad guy as morally uncomplicated.

I’m not sure I’d say the West explains modern Mormon attitudes toward violence, but I suspect it belongs somewhere in the genealogy.

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:11 pm
A few observations about violence in Mormonism are also in order. In present culture, which is a continuation of what we were brought up with, violence for Mormons is no big deal. The Book of Mormon is violent, but it's cartoon violence. Like in the Road Runner. A tale with lots of cartoon violence and war is the driving force of God's glory recapturing the earth at various time periods. Last Days prophecy is all about bodies laying everywhere and rotting and Jesus is going to come down and burn everyone who didn't believe like Mormons did -- will serve them right. Mormons have a lot of cartoonish war fantasies.

Mormons are largely desensitized to violence. If it's a war movie with good guys prevailing then it makes it all that more dramatic. My mom would watch war movies with dad and only cringe at the cussing, as Dr. Scratch observed. I guess it was a moral obligation to show disapproval for using that kind of language. A few hundred people are about to drown in a submarine and that one soldier could have said "gosh darn" instead.

Well, it's interesting, as I think it may be an open question as to whether apologists are more open to swearing in war movies. They might be. Apologists have long been aware of the cartoon violence of the Book of Mormon and been embarrassed by this. I think it was Jack Welch who wrote an essay for FARMS in the 90s about the beheading of Laban, and tried to recast it as gruesome and unsettling, basically as R-rated. Growing up, we reenacted the story of the plates for FHE. We dressed up for our parts and had cutout swords and everything. This is not the sort of thing the apologists want. Grant Hardy's epic work tries to make the Book of Mormon more serious and dark for the mature entertainment palate. Mormon apologists want the Book of Mormon to be taken seriously as a dark, gritty exploration of the raw human condition when in reality, it's a light-hearted hero's romp with zero dramatic value. It's Disney.

But yes, reenacting the Laban story with cutout swords is exactly the "wholesome extreme violence" that this poster was talking about. But this is a more complex matter for apologists because if it's too wholesome nobody takes it seriously.

A final thought is in order here, Mormons have desensitized themselves to the suffering of others, but this is not merely rooted in the Book of Mormon's inability to be taken serious as real literature about violence. It's their beliefs or culture surrounding the afterlife. When people die that don't matter to them personally, it's no big deal because they are in a better place now, even Hitler will get the Telestial Kingdom. It's like Pac-Man dying except he just respawns in a different maze. No big deal. They'll get the gospel in the next life and have their chance, what's the big deal? Like if you're going to cutoff USAID and hundreds of thousands of people die as a result, Mormons will say exactly this. No big deal, they're in a better place now anyway,.

But it's fascinating, because I've had yet more experiences that reinforce my belief that when it comes to themselves personally, if they don't fear death, they don't go towards it with the high beliefs of reuniting with everyone like they preached about constantly up to that point. It's like reality is setting in. Anyway, the main point was they are desensitized to the death and suffering of others; such suffering and death is a cartoonish thing and Pac-Man always respawns anyway.
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Limnor »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:22 pm
Some interesting points here. I wonder if part of this is being located in the American West rather than something generated entirely by Mormon theology. Early Mormon culture matured in a nineteenth-century western environment in which vigilantism, militias, personal self-redress, armed conflict, and extralegal violence were hardly exotic. Utah wasn’t culturally sealed off from that world; in many respects it participated in it.
I think I’ve cracked the code. You finished Talbot and now everything looks like a Mormon boundary case.
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by The Before »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:31 pm
I think I’ve cracked the code. You finished Talbot and now everything looks like a Mormon boundary case.
Not Talbot, actually, though I can see why you’d think so. The framework I’m using is broader than the “Mormon question” literature anyways. I’m interested in the recurring American process by which supposedly peripheral groups become useful sites for defining citizenship, domesticity, religion, race, sexuality, and political legitimacy.

Talbot’s contribution is not simply “Mormons were a boundary case,” but that the Mormon controversy exposed tensions already built into nineteenth-century American political culture.

So if everything looks like a boundary case, perhaps that is because “Americanness” has historically been produced through a great many of them. Mormonism is interesting because it is unusually legible.

But Let us not derail this thread with meta discussion.
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Doctor Scratch
B.H. Roberts Chair of Mopologetic Studies
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Location: Cassius University

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Doctor Scratch »

You have to wonder sometimes about the naïveté of the Mopologists:
The Afore wrote:
Jamison Meurer wrote:In addition to Dr. Peterson's cogent point, most people watching a movie understand that the violence in it is fake. There is no way to fake nudity or profanity. Any examples of either in a movie is the real deal.
Excellent points. Thanks for making them.
"There is no way to fake nudity or profanity"? Really? Someone involved in filmmaking thinks that this is an "excellent" point? Has he never heard of dubbing? Do these two think that every child who utters the "F" word in a film actually said "F" during the production process? I get the point that the audience will hear the profanity, but what are these two thinking?

Meanwhile, has neither of these two seen Boogie Nights? Or the cult 1980s horror film, Society? Does Meurer think that the filmmakers just magically managed to find an actress whose breasts (or her head, I guess?) were put on backwards? And what about David Fincher's 1999 film Fight Club, which features a character, played by the musician Meat Loaf, who is referred to--rather unkindly--as "Bitch Tits." Do these two "bright lights" of Mopologetics think that those were Brother Loaf's actual mammaries? Or that all of these examples are "the real deal"?

In any case: there is definitely something peculiar at play here. The Mopologists are happy to lap up the "wholesome extreme violence" ("bad guy got a bike seat shoved through his neck"), but "nudity or profanity" is clearly seen as something that is far more menacing and threatening. Why is the bike-seat-through-the-neck acceptable, but Mark Wahlberg's hot-dog-esque fake wiener at the end of Boogie Nights is something to be regarded with grave apprehension?

I think Dr. Robbers is correct that all of this points to a certain lack of empathy, and that Mormonism's cartoonish, Pac-Man-esque theology has something to do with it. But I think the Mopologists are glossing over the reasons why they are so obviously threatened by "nudity or profanity." (And correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't the Afore, in a critical post aimed at Hugh Grant, admit to watching Sirens, which features copious amounts of gratuitous nudity? Perhaps he was just watching it to reinforce his white-hot hatred of Hugh Grant, and the naked bodies of Elle MacPherson et al. were merely "there" incidentally?) The Proprietor admitted that part of the alleged "danger" (in his view) of nudity in movies is that it might tempt people into....Well, he doesn't say, exactly.

To build on what I just said: the violence in films also isn't always "fake." Take one of the Proprietor's favorite movies of all time--Groundhog Day. There is a scene in the film where Andie MacDowell slaps Phil, the Bill Murray character. In a behind-the-scenes interview, MacDowell reveals that she wound up slapping him repeatedly, over multiple takes, and that she was really hitting him pretty hard. And Linda Blair, from The Exorcist, has said that she suffered permanent physical harm from the demands of her performance in that film. What you see on screen is not "fake" exactly, though I guess that, given that the movie is about the (at least) partial triumph of the "Whore of Babylon," then maybe this isn't the best example.
"If, while hoping that everybody else will be honest and so forth, I can personally prosper through unethical and immoral acts without being detected and without risk, why should I not?." --Daniel Peterson, 6/4/14
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Gadianton »

That guy is completely missing the point. In fact, he's contradicting Dan's point, which is the automatic "incitement" (of repressed men). It's hilarious that he falsely claims to be involved in contemporary film during the birth of AI. So AI nudity isn't "nudity" because it isn't real? He'll take his kids to see Tilly Norwood nude because it's not real?
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Limnor »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:11 pm
A few observations about violence in Mormonism are also in order.
Thank you for this, Gad. I had been thinking the underlying idea was basically, “Well, it’s okay because the bad guys deserve it. They hardly qualify as real people.”

There’s a bit I wouldn’t mind exploring a bit further, however. Do you think apologists are actually trying to have it both ways: seeking a darker, grittier, morally serious reading of the book, while also retaining the Disney version, where the violence doesn’t require much moral thought because the good guys and bad guys are already sorted out for you?
User avatar
Hound of Heaven
God
Posts: 1284
Joined: Wed Dec 13, 2023 5:13 pm

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Hound of Heaven »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:11 pm
A few observations about violence in Mormonism are also in order. In present culture, which is a continuation of what we were brought up with, violence for Mormons is no big deal. The Book of Mormon is violent, but it's cartoon violence. Like in the Road Runner. A tale with lots of cartoon violence and war is the driving force of God's glory recapturing the earth at various time periods. Last Days prophecy is all about bodies laying everywhere and rotting and Jesus is going to come down and burn everyone who didn't believe like Mormons did -- will serve them right. Mormons have a lot of cartoonish war fantasies.

Mormons are largely desensitized to violence. If it's a war movie with good guys prevailing then it makes it all that more dramatic. My mom would watch war movies with dad and only cringe at the cussing, as Dr. Scratch observed. I guess it was a moral obligation to show disapproval for using that kind of language. A few hundred people are about to drown in a submarine and that one soldier could have said "gosh darn" instead.

Well, it's interesting, as I think it may be an open question as to whether apologists are more open to swearing in war movies. They might be. Apologists have long been aware of the cartoon violence of the Book of Mormon and been embarrassed by this. I think it was Jack Welch who wrote an essay for FARMS in the 90s about the beheading of Laban, and tried to recast it as gruesome and unsettling, basically as R-rated. Growing up, we reenacted the story of the plates for FHE. We dressed up for our parts and had cutout swords and everything. This is not the sort of thing the apologists want. Grant Hardy's epic work tries to make the Book of Mormon more serious and dark for the mature entertainment palate. Mormon apologists want the Book of Mormon to be taken seriously as a dark, gritty exploration of the raw human condition when in reality, it's a light-hearted hero's romp with zero dramatic value. It's Disney.

But yes, reenacting the Laban story with cutout swords is exactly the "wholesome extreme violence" that this poster was talking about. But this is a more complex matter for apologists because if it's too wholesome nobody takes it seriously.

A final thought is in order here, Mormons have desensitized themselves to the suffering of others, but this is not merely rooted in the Book of Mormon's inability to be taken serious as real literature about violence. It's their beliefs or culture surrounding the afterlife. When people die that don't matter to them personally, it's no big deal because they are in a better place now, even Hitler will get the Telestial Kingdom. It's like Pac-Man dying except he just respawns in a different maze. No big deal. They'll get the gospel in the next life and have their chance, what's the big deal? Like if you're going to cutoff USAID and hundreds of thousands of people die as a result, Mormons will say exactly this. No big deal, they're in a better place now anyway,.

But it's fascinating, because I've had yet more experiences that reinforce my belief that when it comes to themselves personally, if they don't fear death, they don't go towards it with the high beliefs of reuniting with everyone like they preached about constantly up to that point. It's like reality is setting in. Anyway, the main point was they are desensitized to the death and suffering of others; such suffering and death is a cartoonish thing and Pac-Man always respawns anyway.
Mormons are largely desensitized to violence?? Really! Maybe just maybe being selective about empathy isn't a psychological defect Mormons suffer with alone. Maybe human beings in general have tendency to show less empathy towards groups they dislike.

Which brings me to this post from DrCamnPP. You're arguing Mormons are somehow desensitized to violence and suffering of others because of Mormon theology. Meanwhile , on this board , DrCamnPP is mocking people for wanting grace and empathy and says they want to be treated the exact opposite of the way they vote worship and behave. DrCamnPP and just about every exmormon on this board is choosing to use selective empathy towards people they dislike politically and religiously!

So before you attempt to diagnose millions of Mormons as "desensitized" to suffering, perhaps we should all acknowledge the obvious right here in front of us!!

Not only how DrCamnPP treats others, but how exmorons this board treat Mormons like MG2.0 or Dr. Peterson! Are the exmormons on this board using selective empathy?

But if you want to believe Nephi is somehow turning Mormons into violence desensitized sociopaths, be my guest, but realize it's not a Mormon problem we're talking about, it's a human problem and the idiot DrCamnPP and his post below proves my point!!

Image
User avatar
Doctor CamNC4Me
God
Posts: 11198
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:04 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Doctor CamNC4Me »

Image
Last edited by Doctor CamNC4Me on Mon Sep 28, 2026 9:32 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Hiring a part-time news entertainment anchor as SecDef, what could go wrong?
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Gadianton »

Limnor wrote:Do you think apologists are actually trying to have it both ways: seeking a darker, grittier, morally serious reading of the book, while also retaining the Disney version
Yes. In fact, the search for scholarly respectability, complexity, and for what is appealing to the vain imaginations of the world is entirely tied to their embarrassment and is optional. If they didn't need to endure the knowing smiles, they would completely embrace the Disney version without a second thought. So they don't try to reconcile these worlds, they put on a certain face to defend complexity. The perfect analog here is MG. How many hours has he invested in topics related to uncertainty and the problem of knowledge (without really grasping the subject matter) for no reason other than a defense for his utter certainty in his religious beliefs? Do you think he has any interest in those topics if the heat is off his religion?
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Gadianton »

Hound wrote:Mormons are largely desensitized to violence?? Really! Maybe just maybe being selective about empathy isn't a psychological defect Mormons suffer with alone. Maybe human beings in general have tendency to show less empathy towards groups they dislike.
Thank you for at least somewhat responding to what I wrote, unlike The Before, who quoted me and then went on his own completely unrelated tangent.

You are correct that this isn't something that Mormons alone struggle with, the Nazi party is a perfect example of the problem from history, and interestingly, Mormons integrated quite easily with Nazism while other religions, like Jehovah's Witnesses did not do so well. Their firm doctrine against war and violence perhaps has fought against the tendency for their own in-group to completely throw the outgroup to the wolves. They have many of the same problems, largely with authoritarianism, but perhaps the unusual doctrines they rally around has lessoned their tolerance of violence both direct and by proxy. On the one hand you have a religion based on a fake history almost entirely about war and religious obedience leading to victory in war, and on the other, you have a religion based on eschewing war, and refusing to be the ax by which the state heweth.

So you are correct that it's not just Mormons, but incorrect in your insinuation of simplistic relativism that everyone is equally guilty automatically.
DrCamnPP is mocking people for wanting grace and empathy and says they want to be treated the exact opposite of the way they vote worship and behave. DrCamnPP and just about every exmormon on this board is choosing to use selective empathy towards people they dislike politically and religiously!
bzzzt. So lets say a band of Nazis at the behest of Hitler knock on the door of a house to extract a Jewish family hiding in the basement. What you're saying, is that if that an observer starts calling the band of Nazis names and criticizing them for what they are doing, that this observer is selectively empathetic and just as bad as the Nazis. That's dumber than crap, hound.
Not only how DrCamnPP treats others, but how exmorons this board treat Mormons like MG2.0 or Dr. Peterson! Are the exmormons on this board using selective empathy?
Don't be ridiculous. There is a massive difference between how anybody treats anyone on a message board, and how people treat others in real life, and also how people treat others by proxy through their collective action. Words on a message board aren't violence, please don't be so woke.
But if you want to believe Nephi is somehow turning Mormons into violence desensitized sociopaths, be my guest, but realize it's not a Mormon problem we're talking about, it's a human problem and the idiot DrCamnPP and his post below proves my point!!
Again, incorrect, on many levels. Being desensitized to violence doesn't make somebody a sociopath. I never said Mormons were sociopaths. Perhaps they'd be ideal subjects for pain inflictors in a Milgram experiment, but this is not sociopathology.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
Post Reply