Analytics wrote: ↑Sun Aug 03, 2025 1:41 pm
What is “cultural Marxism”? You keep using the term, but if I doesn’t mean what I suggested (the battle between proletariat red-neck culture and bourgeoisie New York Times culture), then what does it mean?
To me, cultural Marxism is the impact of Marxist theory on our intellectual/cultural lexicon, the various theories springing from Marxist thinkers that are regularly employed in scholarship and activism. I have no idea why we would use "the battle between proletariat redneck culture and bourgeoisie New York Times culture" as anything but a seriously reductive and misrepresentative description, or perhaps caricature, of what cultural Marxism is. That definition sounds more like an example of the deployment of the term for polemical purposes or a polemical description of the context of its deployment.
I will add to these comments on Cultural Marxism the hilarity of the sites in Google results that dismiss the term "Cultural Marxism" as an anti-semitic conspiracy theory. Seriously, practically all of the top Google results for a search for that term come up with some kind of polemical propaganda either denying the existence of the term as anything legitimate or attacking things for being "Cultural Marxism," depending on the political bent of the author. Sadly, all of these things present themselves as serious commentary seeking to enlighten others on the actual meaning of "Cultural Marxism," but in point of fact it is all just a bunch of provocative, hysterical nonsense.
Consider the following:
In the morass of political propaganda, I was able to pull up a paper from the early 2000s written by a UCLA professor (Douglas Kellner) in its School of Education (an academic pursuit that right-wingers hate) and unironically titled, "Cultural Marxism and Cultural Studies." It is essentially a history of the influence of Marxism on critical theory, etc.
For access to it, see:
https://pages.gseis.ucla.edu/faculty/ke ... arxism.pdf
It is likely the case that the right-wingers, who identified Kellner as one of the Dirty Thirty, or the most politically extreme (on the Left) professors, had Kellner especially in mind when They latched onto the term as something to distort and attack.
Kellner has written a lot of anti-Trump stuff, his 2016 book,
American Nightmare: Donald Trump, Media Spectacle, and Authoritarian Populism being an early representative example.
So, no, I do not agree that Cultural Marxism is fake or a conspiracy theory. It was something that left-wing professors unironically talked about as existing before it became the bugaboo of the right-wing assholes that hated these guys and sought to attack them. After distorting the meaning of Cultural Marxism, right-wingers provoked left-wingers into responding by attacking the caricature the rightwing created. Sadly, the leftists went further by saying that Cultural Marxism was only ever a made-up conspiracy theory. I think the Kellner paper speaks for itself. My Politifact says, "False," Cultural Marxism is not just a conspiracy theory. It was, once upon a time, a descriptive term defined and used fruitfully by left-wing academicians.
canpakes wrote: ↑Sat Aug 02, 2025 7:35 pm
Strangely, voting for Trump and having him land in office did not silence every opinion that MAGA deems bothersome or ‘unfun’.
The ‘solution’ seems worthless, and the choice to think that it was a solution to begin with seems driven by weak and vindictive behavior, no better than the worst that any ‘radical leftist’ would suggest.
Yes! MAGA is a scam from top to bottom. A complete scam. Trump is a con man. The only way anything works for him is if it adds money to his wallet and attention to his brand. All he has done is exploit the already existing feeling against political correctness and identity politics to serve his own ends.
But, the thing is, that feeling against political correctness and identity politics did/does exist. Should we pretend that it did not just because Trump is a con artist? In other words, should we lie to ourselves and others about how numerous people felt/feel about political correctness and identity politics?
I would love it if people shared my feelings about being fair and accepting of others. If They do not, I will not pretend that They do, or just assume that the only reason They disagree is because They are fundamentally bad people (doubtless, some of them are bad people, as bad people do exist). I will also not pretend that there have not been some silly extremes as people struggled to figure out how to achieve fairness and acceptance.
When MSNBC starts lying to me about how unpopular Bernie Sanders is, or how identity politics are only problematic when right-wingers do it, etc., etc., I just laugh and change the channel. Lies are lies. Also, I do not believe that everyone involved in the American Eagle ad campaign is a Nazi or knowingly promoting Nazi ideology.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.