I might just do that, Zosimus . Parisian-educated Luman Walters who mentored Joseph would have appreciated the celebratory expression "adieu" mentioned a total of eight times in the Arabian Nights.
Hmmm, I wonder...
anielPeterson
noel
5 hours ago
noel: "Instead of going over to discussmormonism I thought i might get the opportunity to ask Dan some hard questions civilly. I am not like Shulem. I have researched the facsimile issue over and over. Gee and Kerry Muhlestein do not seem to be mentioning much about the Book of Abraham. Skousen is convinced that the facsimiles should be dropped. I can find sources online and in libraries that don't mention the church. Imagine if when facsimile 1 was pulled from the body intact and the standing figure had the jackal head and a jar instead of a knife. Here is an example someone at the University of Exeter sent me to my inquiry.
https://docs.google.com/doc...
This place will almost always be a better venue for asking serious questions than the Discuss Mormons message board is.
I don't see a clear question in the sentences above, though. Can you formulate one for me? I'll be happy to pass it on to Drs. Muhlestein and Gee and perhaps a couple of others.
noel: "Another [sic] question for the honest inquirer is why does the "slave" in facsimile have one ear. Was it Anubis (who has 2 ears). A look at the printing plate seems to show some chiseling."
Is that the question that you want me to forward to my friends?
noel: "A problem is how do you tell someone they might be wrong without an attitude of mocking."
I'm not sure that either Dr. Muhlestein or Dr. Gee would have any especially authoritative answer to that question.
So, the two have no ability to answer without mocking? DCP's response is oh so very, very correct.Daniel Peterson wrote: noel: "A problem is how do you tell someone they might be wrong without an attitude of mocking."
I'm not sure that either Dr. Muhlestein or Dr. Gee would have any especially authoritative answer to that question.
The most academically honest position Drs. Muhlestein and Gee could take would be to concede all of Shulem's findings on the Book of Abraham.Marcus wrote: ↑Thu Nov 21, 2024 6:20 amSo, the two have no ability to answer without mocking? DCP's response is oh so very, very correct.Daniel Peterson wrote: noel: "A problem is how do you tell someone they might be wrong without an attitude of mocking."
I'm not sure that either Dr. Muhlestein or Dr. Gee would have any especially authoritative answer to that question.
Don,Shulem wrote: ↑Sun Sep 24, 2023 2:24 pmQUESTION for Don Bradley:Don Bradley wrote: ↑Tue Sep 12, 2023 6:42 amThere are unquestionably parallels between Joseph Smith and Mormon: they are closely parallel figures. I would hope everyone would recognize that. What people may disagree on is just the source and meaning of the parallels.
When Joseph Smith dictated (translated) the story of Mormon, did he recognize the 11-15-24 parallels?
[ ] Yes
[ ] No
Many years ago, I worked very hard as an online apologist while living faithfully within the confines of Mormonism and even maintained an extensive website, viewable today in the archives. I specialized in Book of Abraham apologetics and pushed for the Catalyst Theory and principles of representationalism long before other Mormon apologists would seriously consider alternative ideas whereas the Missing Roll Theory was generally accepted as the only viable theory excuse to explain the Book of Abraham. I remember well the works of Hugh Nibley and when John Gee began his career as an Egyptologist.
Lol. That is patently untrue. DCP does not answer questions. The archives here are full of substantial answers to questions that put DCP and his playground-peer-moderated Interpreter to shame.
Do you really think DCP believes he doesn't answer questions? If he is going to post that remote viewing and clairvoyance is real wouldn't that cloud his judgement when interacting with critics. He presupposes another realm of existence and belittles people that scoff at it.Marcus wrote: ↑Thu Nov 28, 2024 8:42 pmLol. That is patently untrue. DCP does not answer questions. The archives here are full of substantial answers to questions that put DCP and his playground-peer-moderated Interpreter to shame.
Shulem's work is far superior. I really wonder why Noel had to put that in, is he trying to get DCP's approval?