Page 1 of 1

Would Mamdani have endorsed Joseph Smith for President in 1844?

Posted: Wed Jun 24, 2026 8:57 pm
by sock puppet
Consider that Joseph Smith tried communal living in Kirtland in the 1830s, as did several cities in Utah into the 1870s. It was called the United Order (or United Firm). In D&C 42, it is provided that
33 And again, if there shall be properties in the hands of the church, or any individuals of it, more than is necessary for their support after this first consecration, which is a residue to be consecrated unto the bishop, it shall be kept to administer to those who have not, from time to time, that every man who has need may be amply supplied and receive according to his wants.
Granted, this socialism within the LDS Church failed in Kirtland due to massive debt, rapid land speculation and internal disagreements. The systems failed in Utah cities largely failed due to aggressive federal anti-polygamy laws, economic pressures from the transcontinental railroad, internal division regarding private ownership, and government efforts to dissolve communal monopolies in favor of competitive free-market capitalism.

But is it yet Mormon God's philosophical thinking? How does it square with the prevalent political ideology of the LDS, particularly those in Idaho, Wyoming, Utah and Arizona?

On February 7, 1844, Joseph Smith in Nauvoo wrote
And when a neighboring realm petition to join the union of the sons of liberty, my voice would be come--yea, come, Texas; come, Mexico; come, Canada; and come, all the work: let us be brethren, let us be one great family, and let there be a universal peace.
Open borders approach? rather than the close-the-gates nationalism prevalent in the U.S. and Europe? Hmmm.

Continuing in that same February 7, 1844 piece,
Abolish the cruel custom of prisons (except certain cases), penitentiaries, courts-martial for desertion; and let reason and friendship reign over the ruins of ignorance and barbarity; yea, I would, as the universal friend of man, open the prisons, open the eyes, open the ears, and open the hearts of all people, to behld and enjoy freedom--unadulterated freedom; and God, who once cleansed the violence of the earth with a flood, whose Son laid down His life for the salvation of all His Father gave Him out of the world, and who has promised that He will come and purify the world again with fire in the last days, should be supplicated by me for the good of all people. With the highest esteem, I am a friend of virtue and of the people.
Did Mamdani simply coopt Joseph Smith's/Mormon God's political playbook? It sure seems like Mamdani is more in line with these precepts than say late 20th Century and early 21st Century LDS, both the bulk of its leaders and the bulk of the members. Why don't LDS aspire to and take guidance from the restoration prophet's pronouncements?

Re: Would Mamdani have endorsed Joseph Smith for President in 1844?

Posted: Thu Jun 25, 2026 12:21 am
by Everybody Wang Chung
I guarantee if Joseph Smith walked into a modern Utah or Idaho testimony meeting and advocated for open borders, prison abolition, and a wealth-redistributing socialist commune, Mormons would probably report him to the bishop for apostasy, or throw rocks at him.

Re: Would Mamdani have endorsed Joseph Smith for President in 1844?

Posted: Thu Jun 25, 2026 8:00 pm
by sock puppet
Everybody Wang Chung wrote: ↑
Thu Jun 25, 2026 12:21 am
I guarantee if Joseph Smith walked into a modern Utah or Idaho testimony meeting and advocated for open borders, prison abolition, and a wealth-redistributing socialist commune, Mormons would probably report him to the bishop for apostasy, or throw rocks at him.
LDS prophets have always had to be a bit circumspect out of fear that members would reject a new "revelation" that goes too far. For example, there was not only pushback in the big 15 (Mark Peterson and Bruce McConkie) to the 1978 "revelation" extending the priesthood and temple rites to blacks, but wider spread among the members, particularly the BIC crowd. Now, in the Trump/MAGA era, Nelson and currently Oaks have also had to be extra circumspect so that the other leaders and large numbers of members would not chafe at some new directive that could be perceived as not in line with the Trump/MAGA agenda. The LDS prophet's throne is a bit more tarnished now than it was in early 2015.

Re: Would Mamdani have endorsed Joseph Smith for President in 1844?

Posted: Sat Jun 27, 2026 5:45 pm
by Philo Sofee
sock puppet wrote: ↑
Thu Jun 25, 2026 8:00 pm
Everybody Wang Chung wrote: ↑
Thu Jun 25, 2026 12:21 am
I guarantee if Joseph Smith walked into a modern Utah or Idaho testimony meeting and advocated for open borders, prison abolition, and a wealth-redistributing socialist commune, Mormons would probably report him to the bishop for apostasy, or throw rocks at him.
LDS prophets have always had to be a bit circumspect out of fear that members would reject a new "revelation" that goes too far. For example, there was not only pushback in the big 15 (Mark Peterson and Bruce McConkie) to the 1978 "revelation" extending the priesthood and temple rites to blacks, but wider spread among the members, particularly the BIC crowd. Now, in the Trump/MAGA era, Nelson and currently Oaks have also had to be extra circumspect so that the other leaders and large numbers of members would not chafe at some new directive that could be perceived as not in line with the Trump/MAGA agenda. The LDS prophet's throne is a bit more tarnished now than it was in early 2015.
LOL! It's always a blessing to see the Lord's prophets following the politician's agendas...... :lol: