Joe's Ranch

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
Morley
God
Posts: 2659
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 6:17 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Morley »

MG, as a good faith poster, I'm sure you're still working on your response to this, or you would have posted it by now:
Morley wrote: ↑
Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:29 am
Morley wrote: ↑
Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:11 am
Here’s your claim:

You make it sound like this is the consensus (or at least a mainstream) opinion in what you’re calling ‘Judeo-Christian theology.’
And here’s the original post, that started my objection.
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:04 pm
Another problem you might run into if you are sending the thief directly to heaven is that the ancient Israelites believed in Sheol, and the classical Greeks believed in Hades. Both terms [Hades and Sheol] described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness.
The bold is yours. You’re going to show evidence that “the ancient Israelites believed in Sheol, and the classical Greeks believed in Hades.” And that “both terms (Hades and Sheol) described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness”.

No one is debating whether or not early Christians or some factions of Second Temple Judaism considered these concepts.
I'm genuinely interested in where you got the flatly-stated concept that "the ancient Israelites believed in Sheol, and the classical Greeks believed in Hades. Both terms [Hades and Sheol] described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness."

I couldn't find support for this in the any of the links you referenced. And as I understand it, these are certainly not common views among either Greek or Jewish scholars, though you seem to imply that they are.

You were certain enough about this that you both bolded and italicized the last part of your statement. Since you're basically shouting this from the rooftops, perhaps you'll explain where the hell it comes from.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

Morley wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 1:57 pm
...“both terms (Hades and Sheol) described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness”.
At this source while reading I read:
The message of these texts is that everyone goes to sheʾol. Jacob will join Joseph in sheʾol, and Saul will join Samuel, but the wicked kings of Babylon and Egypt will be there as well. The mighty and the meek, righteous and wicked, all end up the same way. Death is the great equalizer.
https://www.thetorah.com/article/no-hea ... on.%20Prof.
Reading the surrounding material there seems to be a conversation among the Rabbi's on whether this is the grave or an actual location/place.

Second Temple Judaism developed this further with the help of Greek thought.

The ancient Greeks thought of Hades as being:
...a place of “moldering horror” where ordinary people — and even heroes — went after they died. This place was immersed in misty darkness and sequestered by the dreaded River Styx.
https://europe.factsanddetails.com/arti ... l?hl=en-US
My point is that the idea of an afterlife where the wicked and the righteous go after death has been around a long time and that LDS theology fleshed this doctrine out.

I, admittedly, am not a scholar of the ancient world. Just an interested bystander with curiosity.

I don't know what your background is but if you can shed more light on this subject, that might be a good topic for a new thread. Psuedo(Sp.?) Paul and others (Gadianton?) might be willing to jump in.

Responding in good faith but lacking in a through in depth knowledge...

Regards,
MG
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

Translation: I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed. The idea that I didn’t even read it doesn’t automatically equate to lack of good faith. Maybe someone with a better understanding of the subject can come along and make my argument for me.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:35 pm
Translation: I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed. The idea that I didn’t even read it doesn’t automatically equate to lack of good faith. Maybe someone with a better understanding of the subject can come along and make my argument for me.
Or add flesh to the topic being discussed and/or brought up by someone who is not an expert.

Care to add some more rather than take away or criticize?

As I said, this might be an interesting topic for another thread. You could start it off?

Regards,
MG
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:41 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:35 pm
Translation: I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed. The idea that I didn’t even read it doesn’t automatically equate to lack of good faith. Maybe someone with a better understanding of the subject can come along and make my argument for me.
Or add flesh to the topic being discussed and/or brought up by someone who is not an expert.

Care to add some more rather than take away or criticize?

As I said, this might be an interesting topic for another thread. You could start it off?

Regards,
MG
I actually would be quite interested in your knowledge/scholarship in this area. And if it lends credence to where you think Jesus met the thief after the crucifixion.

Doctrinally, it’s kind of a big deal, right?

Regards,
MG
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Marcus »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:35 pm
Translation: I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed. The idea that I didn’t even read it doesn’t automatically equate to lack of good faith. Maybe someone with a better understanding of the subject can come along and make my argument for me.
Excellent translation. Especially this part:
"I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed."

Over and over and over.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

“I actually would be quite interested in your knowledge/scholarship in this area.”

I don’t believe you.
User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3957
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:35 pm
Translation: I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed. The idea that I didn’t even read it doesn’t automatically equate to lack of good faith. Maybe someone with a better understanding of the subject can come along and make my argument for me.
We should definitely pity someone whose strategy relies entirely on throwing a smoke bomb of half-baked citations, sham links and praying a smarter adult wanders by to finish their homework for them.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 5:49 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:35 pm
Translation: I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed. The idea that I didn’t even read it doesn’t automatically equate to lack of good faith. Maybe someone with a better understanding of the subject can come along and make my argument for me.
We should definitely pity someone whose strategy relies entirely on throwing a smoke bomb of half-baked citations, sham links and praying a smarter adult wanders by to finish their homework for them.
Wang said:

The last time I let Fibber trick me into clicking a link was 2015. He swore up and down it was a clip about the church’s explosive growth in the U.S. Liminor, it was actually an hour long David Bednar talk/address about a returned missionary who broke up with his girlfriend because she had multiple ear piercings. Some psychological wounds never truly heal. Fibber is an idiot.

And this:

Liminor, thank you for your concern, my friend. It has been a long, harrowing road of recovery from the devastating trauma of Fibber’s deception. I’m taking it one day and one Irish coffee at a time.

Ten years, Liminor. Ten long years of staring at the ceiling at 3:00 AM, asking myself, why? Why would Fibber do this? The sheer audacity, the betrayal and complete dorkiness. It has taken a village of supportive friends just to help me piece my shattered reality back together. I wouldn’t wish Fibber’s betrayal on my worst enemy. Some scars will never heal.
I think we should pity someone who is a chronic liar and makes up false accusations and stories. And in some respects worse still, that Limnor would let him play him like a fiddle.

Weird.

Regards,
MG
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 5:49 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:35 pm
Translation: I didn’t really read what I cited, and it doesn’t quite support what I originally claimed. The idea that I didn’t even read it doesn’t automatically equate to lack of good faith. Maybe someone with a better understanding of the subject can come along and make my argument for me.
We should definitely pity someone whose strategy relies entirely on throwing a smoke bomb of half-baked citations, sham links and praying a smarter adult wanders by to finish their homework for them.
You know maybe MG deserves a little more credit. After all it takes a lot of work to find a source that doesn’t support your argument, and then spin it as if it does. And if that doesn’t work, fall back to conspiracy theories. That’s not something just anyone can do.

On a serious note, I’ve noticed that there is a baked in response to the pity card at the end of the ceremony when the preacher says he feels sorry for them. Even mercy is used against the faithful Mormon. In truth, I do feel a little pity, but knowing that my pity is a tool against me is a bit unsettling.
Post Reply