MG wrote: Just yesterday I mentioned that I’m not on board with God having a body of literal flesh and bone.
In that case you're not really on board with the apostasy and restoration since 49% of that is God having a body, 49% is baptism by immersion/baptism for the dead, and 2% is everything else.
You can't really say the number 1 distinct idea of Mormonism that was "restored" is incorrect.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
I am quite sure the LDS restoration movement passionately rejected the doctrine of predestination and would have held that as a prime example of corrupt creed (westminster confession, etc.).
For the sake of looking for strong points to consider (could reject) I think the LDS church has been clear restoring priesthood, apostolic succession and prophetic leadership is the restoration. There is little point to looking for a new doctrine as restoration though new doctrines became possible as a result. I realize there is a desire to see stuff like temple ritual in the early church lost but I think that is very questionable what is. Safer to argue these are completing expansions made possible by the restoration.
There’s no compelling evidence to suggest that Apostolic succession was needed to be restored. It never went away. Catholicism can trace its line of succession right back to the Apostles. Jesus wasn’t part of a priesthood. Others labelled him a High Priest but there is no evidence that he was ordained to, or passed on, anything resembling what the LDS Church calls “the priesthood”. This is just the church trying to paint a target around a hole that isn’t there.
Levitical Priesthood, no. After the order of Melchizedek, yes.
Genesis records no beginning or end to Melchizedek’s life or priesthood, he serves as a symbol for a priesthood that is permanent and eternal.
I am quite sure the LDS restoration movement passionately rejected the doctrine of predestination and would have held that as a prime example of corrupt creed (westminster confession, etc.).
For the sake of looking for strong points to consider (could reject) I think the LDS church has been clear restoring priesthood, apostolic succession and prophetic leadership is the restoration. There is little point to looking for a new doctrine as restoration though new doctrines became possible as a result. I realize there is a desire to see stuff like temple ritual in the early church lost but I think that is very questionable what is. Safer to argue these are completing expansions made possible by the restoration.
There’s no compelling evidence to suggest that Apostolic succession was needed to be restored. It never went away. Catholicism can trace its line of succession right back to the Apostles. Jesus wasn’t part of a priesthood. Others labelled him a High Priest but there is no evidence that he was ordained to, or passed on, anything resembling what the LDS Church calls “the priesthood”. This is just the church trying to paint a target around a hole that isn’t there.
I’ve been trying to figure out what these “designing corrupters” sought to gain through the Nicene Creed, or even by putting words into Jesus’ mouth.
It’s easy to see how a claim to restored priesthood authority might benefit someone. It gives them the power to administer ordinances, speak for God, and collect tithes. But why wouldn’t the “designing corrupters” do the same thing? Wouldn’t they have held on to the priesthood, for example, to preserve that power?
It just seems like the opposite of what someone who was seeking to corrupt would do.
There’s no compelling evidence to suggest that Apostolic succession was needed to be restored. It never went away. Catholicism can trace its line of succession right back to the Apostles. Jesus wasn’t part of a priesthood. Others labelled him a High Priest but there is no evidence that he was ordained to, or passed on, anything resembling what the LDS Church calls “the priesthood”. This is just the church trying to paint a target around a hole that isn’t there.
I’ve been trying to figure out what these “designing corrupters” sought to gain through the Nicene Creed, or even by putting words into Jesus’ mouth.
It’s easy to see how a claim to restored priesthood authority might benefit someone. It gives them the power to administer ordinances, speak for God, and collect tithes. But why wouldn’t the “designing corrupters” do the same thing? Wouldn’t they have held on to the priesthood, for example, to preserve that power?
It just seems like the opposite of what someone who was seeking to corrupt would do.
I’m of the opinion it was to legitimise maintaining a patriarchy.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
I’m of the opinion it was to legitimise maintaining a patriarchy.
I mean that’s just it—if they had left things the same they would have had that. Why corrupt something that already gave you a patriarchy if that’s what you wanted?
And what would the doctrine of the Trinity have to do with a patriarchy?
MG wrote: Just yesterday I mentioned that I’m not on board with God having a body of literal flesh and bone.
In that case you're not really on board with the apostasy and restoration since 49% of that is God having a body, 49% is baptism by immersion/baptism for the dead, and 2% is everything else.
You can't really say the number 1 distinct idea of Mormonism that was "restored" is incorrect.
God is corporeal. Joseph described what he saw. Later described as a glorified body of flesh and bone. Whatever that is, it's not flesh and bone in the literal sense that we would understand it in our biology class. It's something else.
I'm saying that we ought to be open to the idea that a glorified body of flesh and bone doesn't fit within our biological system which is carbon based.
Whatever it is is beyond our comprehension. We do know through accounts of those who have described God/angels as beings of light that there is something qualitatively different in what is being described as flesh and bone.
Like way different. That's essentially why I said it is pretty hard to think of a God who is compositionally exactly like us.
I’m of the opinion it was to legitimise maintaining a patriarchy.
I mean that’s just it—if they had left things the same they would have had that. Why corrupt something that already gave you a patriarchy if that’s what you wanted?
And what would the doctrine of the Trinity have to do with a patriarchy?
You have to bear in mind Joseph was “new to market”. He had to think up ways to be different from the existing religions of the day. Of which there were a few as there was a religious fever in that time and place. He needed to be unique and stand out from the crowd. “The Restoration” narrative was just Joseph telling people all the other religions weren’t as good as his new one.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
You have to bear in mind Joseph was “new to market”. He had to think up ways to be different from the existing religions of the day. Of which there were a few as there was a religious fever in that time and place. He needed to be unique and stand out from the crowd. “The Restoration” narrative was just Joseph telling people all the other religions weren’t as good as his new one.
That’s a good point, and I think it is supported in the book. For example, I see Joseph reflected in Amalickiah’s flattery and promises to people.
You have to bear in mind Joseph was “new to market”. He had to think up ways to be different from the existing religions of the day.
Yep. That's it! That's why he went through everything he went through in his life and ended up getting killed for his efforts. Maybe it was better/smarter that the other 'new comers' at the time played it safe.
You have to bear in mind Joseph was “new to market”. He had to think up ways to be different from the existing religions of the day. Of which there were a few as there was a religious fever in that time and place. He needed to be unique and stand out from the crowd. “The Restoration” narrative was just Joseph telling people all the other religions weren’t as good as his new one.
That’s a good point, and I think it is supported in the book. For example, I see Joseph reflected in Amalickiah’s flattery and promises to people.
You can see the pattern later on too, whenever Joseph felt his power slipping, he came up with something spectacular. That’s how the First Vision came about, he had need of something to re-establish himself in the sector. A new product development, as it were.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.