Joe's Ranch

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
User avatar
Doctor CamNC4Me
God
Posts: 11198
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:04 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Doctor CamNC4Me »

drumdude wrote: ↑
Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:48 pm
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Thu Oct 29, 2026 10:58 pm
Mormonism is one of the few religions whose version of the afterlife guarantees that families will be separated from some family members for eternity.
“Families can be separated forever, through heavenly father’s plan…”

It’s a great little primary song to scare children into staying Mormon.
What a sad, ugly philosophy Mormons have been instilling into children for nearly two hundred years.

I watched a video yesterday of a young man who was as awful as they come shot down by the police after he killed a rival. His mother, in tears, said something to the effect that she’d see him in Heaven someday.

Awful life aside, how beautiful is it that this woman, despite all her faults and struggles, and the faults and struggles her son endured and caused others, can still picture a reunion with the boy she loved in a glorious celestial home. It’s like holding onto a diamond in a sea of crap.

Meanwhile, Mormons can live a comparatively strict and law abiding life, ne’er a misdemeanor to be found, and still find themselves believing a son isn’t worthy to be with God in Special VIP Heaven because he drinks coffee.

I can’t honestly say who is more unwell.
Hiring a part-time news entertainment anchor as SecDef, what could go wrong?
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Gadianton »

I don't think the Mormon afterlife is worse than other religions. Most Evangelical preachers I used to listen to on the radio take a basic Calvinist stance, which means election is purely random (from our perspective), it doesn't matter how good or bad you were, and it doesn't matter (ultimately) if election urges one to formally accepting the Lord and a life of goodness. And so it's not just separation, but separation with prejudice, with eternal hellfire.

Mormonism "fixes" the part about absurdly unjust punishments from a consequentialist perspective. That's not because Mormonism is inspired, it's because it was invented in the 19th century and had the Enlightenment to work with. If you could make up your own religion as you go along like Smith did you'd probably make up something generally fair to everyone with a slight bias towards yourself and people you like and a slight bias against people you don't like.

There are different senses in the way "together forever" can be taken. One way is literally a matter of having access to each other. The other way is the so-called family bond. Christians believe "til death do us part" and Mormons believe marriage can continue in a marriage capacity, which includes -- you know what. That's the only material difference I could ever think of. Children are "sealed" to their parents, and this is part of the sales pitch, but it doesn't translate to anything material. It's a piece of paper -- government bookkeeping. It doesn't prevent two brothers from mortality hanging out together in heaven nor does it erase the fact that they were born as brothers on earth.

The point remains, of course, that the great promise of government recognition and/or physical access depends on people becoming Mormon at some point. Even if Mormonism fixed the doctrine to allow families to be together forever without restriction it still doesn't make sense. Mormons are big on thinking about "Eternity", but they don't really think about it very seriously. One of my seminary teachers strung a string between two corners of the room and put a black dot on it with a marker, and said this is our life here.

The point is that it's so insignificant, all eternity is leveraged on what you do here, whether to get up and go to seminary, for instance, and so why wouldn't you behave? Of course you would! I absolutely would. I have a tremendous ability to focus on something and get it done when it becomes apparent that it matters. If I really believed in Mormonism, I would be selling my possessions to go on Senior Missions and get as many people as I can in the boat. That others who claim to believe don't do this, tells me they don't really believe.

But, that whole story just doesn't make any sense. It makes no sense due to long time scales and very, very long timescales. Especially in a world of procreation, where you're continually bringing new people into your life by the trillions. Whether or not you spend time with people you grew up with in mortality 50 trillion years later just doesn't matter. You might have a friendship with a person you met in haven for a thousand years, and now the 50 or sixty years you had with people from mortality pales in comparison. And even if you were completely locked into family activities, it starts to become nonsensical very quickly. Relations are formed in the context of survival, risk, tragedy, and all kinds of things that no longer exist in heaven. The "long" time scale covers the absurdity of individual relationships that are basically without context. The very long time scale covers the absurdity of preserving one tiny slice of evolutionary history indefinitely, that includes the human concept of families with roles such as "being a brother" or sister or mother or whatever.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by drumdude »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:06 pm
I don't think the Mormon afterlife is worse than other religions. Most Evangelical preachers I used to listen to on the radio take a basic Calvinist stance, which means election is purely random (from our perspective), it doesn't matter how good or bad you were, and it doesn't matter (ultimately) if election urges one to formally accepting the Lord and a life of goodness. And so it's not just separation, but separation with prejudice, with eternal hellfire.
The percentage of Christians that believe in hell seems to be dwindling quickly. Although with Christian nationalism and the Hegseth version of Christianity on the rise, that may quickly reverse.

Smith seems to have borrowed a lot of his ideas from the universalists. The Book of Mormon initially takes a standard heaven and hell view of the afterlife but as smith grows he increasingly becomes more universalist.

Even Dan Peterson acknowledges a kind of universalism, and that the Mormon afterlife is just different quality grades of endless hedonistic buffet. The family separation isn’t well defined and progression between buffet rooms is debated.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:06 pm
I don't think the Mormon afterlife is worse than other religions.
For me the problem isn't that the Mormon afterlife is worse than other religions. It's that the sales pitch doesn't quite match the product. Not to mention the product is one that satisfies a created need for a solution—one in which a loving Heavenly Father requires money to provide the finished product.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4581
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by I Have Questions »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:06 pm
The point is that it's so insignificant, all eternity is leveraged on what you do here, whether to get up and go to seminary, for instance, and so why wouldn't you behave? Of course you would! I absolutely would. I have a tremendous ability to focus on something and get it done when it becomes apparent that it matters. If I really believed in Mormonism, I would be selling my possessions to go on Senior Missions and get as many people as I can in the boat. That others who claim to believe don't do this, tells me they don't really believe.
It’s an inescapable logical conclusion. If they really did believe, nothing would keep them from serving a Senior Mission, or two. Nothing. It makes their online pleadings about having a strong belief in Mormonism seem very disingenuous. Who are they trying to kid - Us? Themselves? God?
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:36 am
Luke Chapter 23
“42 And he said unto Jesus, Lord, remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom.

43 And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, To day shalt thou be with me in paradise.”

That’s Christ informing a criminal that he would be in paradise living alongside Jesus in the next life. The criminal wasn’t a member of a religious institution, hadn’t paid ten percent of his earnings every month to a religious institution, hadn’t lived the word of wisdom, hadn’t been sealed in a temple, hadn’t served a mission. He had lived the life of a criminal. And Jesus promised him the same heavenly eternal life as Jesus himself.

The LDS church has inserted itself in between the criminal and Jesus, has made up a load of conditions and appointed itself the arbiter of those conditional requirements and placed a physical cost on them. It is charging for something that Christ has already given for free. A protection racket is a good analogy.
Three days after the crucifixion, the resurrected Jesus told Mary Magdalene, "I am not yet ascended to my Father" (John 20:17). Therefore, if Jesus had not yet been to heaven, the "paradise" he visited with the thief could not have been heaven itself.

Didn't Jesus use the word "today" when talking to the thief?

Another problem you might run into if you are sending the thief directly to heaven is that the ancient Israelites believed in Sheol, and the classical Greeks believed in Hades. Both terms described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness.

I'm not sure it's as simple as you're making it out to be.

Regards,
MG
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by drumdude »

MG 2.0 wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:04 pm
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:36 am
Luke Chapter 23
“42 And he said unto Jesus, Lord, remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom.

43 And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, To day shalt thou be with me in paradise.”

That’s Christ informing a criminal that he would be in paradise living alongside Jesus in the next life. The criminal wasn’t a member of a religious institution, hadn’t paid ten percent of his earnings every month to a religious institution, hadn’t lived the word of wisdom, hadn’t been sealed in a temple, hadn’t served a mission. He had lived the life of a criminal. And Jesus promised him the same heavenly eternal life as Jesus himself.

The LDS church has inserted itself in between the criminal and Jesus, has made up a load of conditions and appointed itself the arbiter of those conditional requirements and placed a physical cost on them. It is charging for something that Christ has already given for free. A protection racket is a good analogy.
Three days after the crucifixion, the resurrected Jesus told Mary Magdalene, "I am not yet ascended to my Father" (John 20:17). Therefore, if Jesus had not yet been to heaven, the "paradise" he visited with the thief could not have been heaven itself.

Didn't Jesus use the word "today" when talking to the thief?

Another problem you might run into if you are sending the thief directly to heaven is that the ancient Israelites believed in Sheol, and the classical Greeks believed in Hades. Both terms described an intermediate, post-mortal underworld where all spirits went regardless of their righteousness.

I'm not sure it's as simple as you're making it out to be.

Regards,
MG
MG,

What were the last words Jesus spoke on the Cross?

I’ll give you a hint: you have a lot to pick and choose from. Which is a recurring theme to the Bible as a whole.
MG 2.0
God
Posts: 8847
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by MG 2.0 »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:06 pm
I don't think the Mormon afterlife is worse than other religions. Most Evangelical preachers I used to listen to on the radio take a basic Calvinist stance, which means election is purely random (from our perspective), it doesn't matter how good or bad you were, and it doesn't matter (ultimately) if election urges one to formally accepting the Lord and a life of goodness. And so it's not just separation, but separation with prejudice, with eternal hellfire.

Mormonism "fixes" the part about absurdly unjust punishments from a consequentialist perspective. That's not because Mormonism is inspired, it's because it was invented in the 19th century and had the Enlightenment to work with. If you could make up your own religion as you go along like Smith did you'd probably make up something generally fair to everyone with a slight bias towards yourself and people you like and a slight bias against people you don't like.

There are different senses in the way "together forever" can be taken. One way is literally a matter of having access to each other. The other way is the so-called family bond. Christians believe "til death do us part" and Mormons believe marriage can continue in a marriage capacity, which includes -- you know what. That's the only material difference I could ever think of. Children are "sealed" to their parents, and this is part of the sales pitch, but it doesn't translate to anything material. It's a piece of paper -- government bookkeeping. It doesn't prevent two brothers from mortality hanging out together in heaven nor does it erase the fact that they were born as brothers on earth.

The point remains, of course, that the great promise of government recognition and/or physical access depends on people becoming Mormon at some point. Even if Mormonism fixed the doctrine to allow families to be together forever without restriction it still doesn't make sense. Mormons are big on thinking about "Eternity", but they don't really think about it very seriously. One of my seminary teachers strung a string between two corners of the room and put a black dot on it with a marker, and said this is our life here.

The point is that it's so insignificant, all eternity is leveraged on what you do here, whether to get up and go to seminary, for instance, and so why wouldn't you behave? Of course you would! I absolutely would. I have a tremendous ability to focus on something and get it done when it becomes apparent that it matters. If I really believed in Mormonism, I would be selling my possessions to go on Senior Missions and get as many people as I can in the boat. That others who claim to believe don't do this, tells me they don't really believe.

But, that whole story just doesn't make any sense. It makes no sense due to long time scales and very, very long timescales. Especially in a world of procreation, where you're continually bringing new people into your life by the trillions. Whether or not you spend time with people you grew up with in mortality 50 trillion years later just doesn't matter. You might have a friendship with a person you met in haven for a thousand years, and now the 50 or sixty years you had with people from mortality pales in comparison. And even if you were completely locked into family activities, it starts to become nonsensical very quickly. Relations are formed in the context of survival, risk, tragedy, and all kinds of things that no longer exist in heaven. The "long" time scale covers the absurdity of individual relationships that are basically without context. The very long time scale covers the absurdity of preserving one tiny slice of evolutionary history indefinitely, that includes the human concept of families with roles such as "being a brother" or sister or mother or whatever.
Back to free agency...forcing individuals into an eternal family unit or a specific kingdom of glory against their will or comfort level would violate the core LDS principle of free agency. The sealing of families provides the condition/prospect that everyone will end up exactly where they are most comfortable and willing to abide by the laws of that kingdom.

As you mentioned, eternity is a long time. When we die we go to the world of spirits and truth be told we don't know a lot concerning how things will be sorted out.

What I'm saying is that the sealing ordinance provides the conditional framework by which further progress and certain blessings are bestowed which allows God's children to literally become part of His family unit and live the life that He does. The part that is often left out of the discussion is that not everyone wants to do that.

One small example. Think of all the discussions here in which people put tithing near or at the top of the reasons they would not choose to be a latter-day saint. Or they want to live a certain lifestyle rather than follow all of God's commandments.

Why would/will the afterlife be any different? We separate ourselves in the here and now by what we're willing to do/obey.

C'mon people. We're just not all the same.

Drumdude is saying that everyone will go to heaven. If that is so, will everyone there have the same desires to live the life/existence that God does? It seems that in drumdude's heaven there would quickly develop factions of differences and eventual rebellion.

That would not be heaven. :D

Regards,
MG
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Gadianton »

Back to free agency...forcing individuals into an eternal family unit or a specific kingdom of glory against their will or comfort level would violate the core LDS principle of free agency. The sealing of families provides the condition/prospect that everyone will end up exactly where they are most comfortable and willing to abide by the laws of that kingdom.
That's total spin. The prophets not to mention Hugh Nibley and other Mormon scholars generally point out that the word "damn" means to hold back, not to thrust down. This is an administrative procedure, akin to not letting somebody cross a border into a nicer place vs. putting somebody in a dark hole forever. You are lying if you're saying this is all determined by our volition.

I understand completely what you're saying, which is why in the short story MG 3.0 enters his salvation, the protagonist, MG, ends up spending his eternity with family in a paradise of bbqs, gatherings, and good clean fun, assuming he's at the top of the Celestial Kingdom when in reality, he's in the Terrestrial Kingdom, having failed at his bid to progress to Godhood. But through time and forgetting, the story tries to work out a balance between the subjective world and the objective one, which clearly included an administrative shutdown of MG's progress by higher authorities.
What I'm saying is that the sealing ordinance provides the conditional framework by which further progress and certain blessings are bestowed which allows God's
Which is word salad of nonsense. What material difference would it make for a child to be sealed to their parents? In the Christian heaven, supposing the children make it there, they can hang out, as adults, with their adult parents in a park and talk about family stuff for the next 10 million years if they so choose. They can be "parent and child" in thought, word, and deed, every bit as much as an adult Mormon child hanging out at the same heavenly park with their adult parent. The sealing of husband and wife, as I said, makes a material difference because it allows them to cohabitate and have sex forever. Your insights about ordinances allowing for greater blessings contradicts your suggestions that everyone ends up where they want to be.
One small example. Think of all the discussions here in which people put tithing near or at the top of the reasons they would not choose to be a latter-day saint. Or they want to live a certain lifestyle rather than follow all of God's commandments.
Who said that? If I thought the church was true, that a few meaningless years of life here leverages drastic eternal consequences, I would pay tithing in an instant. PLEASE QUOTE ANY CRITIC here who has ever said that tithing would stop them from being a faithful Mormon. This is a LIE that you and sociopathic authorities tell each other to feel better about yourselves, ITS NOT THE CRITICS, IT'S THE BELIEVERS, who claim that critics are claiming that they wouldn't be part of the Church due to the demand of tithing.
Drumdude is saying that everyone will go to heaven. If that is so, will everyone there have the same desires to live the life/existence that God does? It seems that in drumdude's heaven there would quickly develop factions of differences and eventual rebellion.

That would not be heaven.
This is circular reasoning, and it's self-undermining because once you redefine heaven as entirely psychological, such as MG 3.0 being in heaven in the Terrestrial Kingdom (or Mormons making Hell a paradise as attributed to Brigham Young), you're just redefining what the word heaven means as entirely psychological, and then admitting everyone goes to heaven because everyone goes where they are most comfortable!
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Joe's Ranch

Post by Limnor »

I don’t reject Mormonism because I find tithing inconvenient, or because I want to live a particular lifestyle, or because I’m unwilling to make sacrifices.

I reject Mormonism because it’s not true. Whatever product Mormonism is trying to sell doesn’t exist.
Post Reply