The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4580
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by I Have Questions »

Peterson is becoming increasingly desperate in the face of poor viewing figures...
One of the principal motivations behind our Becoming Brigham series (becomingbrigham.com) is our sense that Brigham Young has been libeled, traduced, and slandered to such an extent that even some innocent members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints have been taken in — and their testimonies of the Restoration damaged — by the constant drumbeat of criticisms and misrepresentations. The attacks on Brother Brigham are, of course, challenging to faith in him as an apostle and a prophet. But they’re also distorted and unjust, when not just flatly false.

The distortions and falsehoods have flown thick and fast since his assumption of Church leadership. The wretchedly awful January 2025 Netflix miniseries American Primeval was an egregious example of such fictionalized pseudohistory, but it’s far from alone. I came across the following just yesterday, written by someone calling himself or herself skylark1250 in response (after a manner of speaking) to the interview that I did a while ago with Jasmin and Neal Rappleye and Steve Smoot at Informed Saints:

Young was a slave holder; read “The Other Slavery” with his taking children from American Indians to work in his wives houses and his farms. The Temple in Salt Lake City was built with the wealth stolen from the murdered families in this wagon train. Young took their gold and made himself a rich man. The cattle in the train, over 800 of them, were later branded with the church brand. The murderers stole money and belongings from the 120 people they murdered, and 38 children were killed. Young saw the wagon train when it came through Salt Lake. The train was advised to attend to their cattle by traveling to Mountain Meadows. It was grazing territory back then before floods changed the landscape. He wanted their wealth. But to steal it, he had to have everyone murdered. Young had blood on his hands. He was no Saint.

There is scarcely an assertion in skylark1250’s comment that would pass muster as accurate history with any serious scholar, Latter-day Saint or otherwise, who has devoted real attention to Brigham Young, the Mountain Meadows Massacre, or the question of slavery in Utah Territory. (See, for instance, my summary remarks at the 2025 FAIR Conference, on “Brigham Young and Slavery.”) Yet this is the kind of thing that we’re facing and that we’re trying to counter, and it’s why I’m asking people, if they have enjoyed or benefitted from Becoming Brigham, to share the series with others, whether in person or — and this would be very helpful — via social media. In the course of Becoming Brigham, we will be addressing every one of these issues — slavery in early Utah Territory, Brigham Young and race, the Mountain Meadows Massacre, Brigham Young and violence, Brigham’s personal character, and more — with the help of expert specialist historians.
I feel prompted to remind Dan that the idea to pursue a defence of the slave-owning tyrant Brigham Young was not his. It was Redbrick Filmworks that pitched him the idea of Brigham Young for the second box office disaster project. Dan himself was reluctant, but devoid of any better ideas. Now, all of a sudden, and with himself cast in a starring role by the Producer (also himself) it's the absolutely most vital thing anyone has ever done since Jesus.

Dan, here's a thought - If your product doesn't interest people it might not be the people's fault...
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Tom
God
Posts: 1190
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm
Location: Sego, Utah
Contact:

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by Tom »

Another week has passed, and Bowdlerizing Brigham’s donation page continues to give donors options to give to the “Six Days in August” film and the “Witnesses” film. Both films, of course, were released in theaters sometime ago. What is the Interpreter Foundation doing with donations directed to the two films? It’s clear that the Interpreter Foundation’s finances require an independent audit.

Posted from Green Jello Flats, Utah
“We live by faith, not by sight” (2 For. 5:7 NIV).
User avatar
Doctor Scratch
B.H. Roberts Chair of Mopologetic Studies
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Location: Cassius University

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by Doctor Scratch »

What do you know? Today Interpreter published a "peer reviewed" blog entry which quotes Brigham Young as saying that there will be slavery--i.e., "servants"--in the Celestial Kingdom. Yes: why *would* people leave the Church after learning about such things? Hopefully, "BB" can persuade them to stay....
"If, while hoping that everybody else will be honest and so forth, I can personally prosper through unethical and immoral acts without being detected and without risk, why should I not?." --Daniel Peterson, 6/4/14
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by drumdude »

Image

The views are still pretty grim. The equivalent of about 5 wards worth of members are watching every day. The church contains currently about 31,676 wards. I’d guess maybe 35-70 wards worth of members are interested in this series on a weekly basis.


This really should have been expected. Witnesses had a pretty small turnout. Six Days in August was much worse. This is scraping the last dregs of members’ enthusiasm for Daniel’s artistic productions.
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by drumdude »

The daily view counts are starting to drop. Becoming Brigham has plateaued and is quickly fading into irrelevance (such that it was.)

Image


DCP can’t stop whinging about how many articles Interpreter slops out onto its website. As if it’s some sort of sign of booming interest. Unfortunately for Dan, the view numbers on this Becoming Brigham project show the real lack of interest for his work. A Potemkin journal, and a bunch of made-for-tv videos that no one is watching.

That’s certainly one way to spend over a million dollars a year of Interpreter’s funds. It’s definitely Red Brick Filmwork’s favorite way to spend it! :lol:

Hey Dan, what’s Interpreter’s next multi million dollar video boondoggle going to be?
User avatar
Tom
God
Posts: 1190
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm
Location: Sego, Utah
Contact:

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by Tom »

drumdude wrote: ↑
Tue Jun 02, 2026 3:29 am
The daily view counts are starting to drop. Becoming Brigham has plateaued and is quickly fading into irrelevance (such that it was.)

Image


DCP can’t stop whinging about how many articles Interpreter slops out onto its website. As if it’s some sort of sign of booming interest. Unfortunately for Dan, the view numbers on this Becoming Brigham project show the real lack of interest for his work. A Potemkin journal, and a bunch of made-for-tv videos that no one is watching.

That’s certainly one way to spend over a million dollars a year of Interpreter’s funds. It’s definitely Red Brick Filmwork’s favorite way to spend it! :lol:

Hey Dan, what’s Interpreter’s next multi million dollar video boondoggle going to be?
In related news, I note that today is the 225th anniversary of Brigham Young’s birth. Here are the words of a song written by Charles Lowell Walker and sung in honor of Young’s seventy-fifth birthday on June 1, 1876:

(tune Tramp tramp tramp)

God bless thy chosen Seer
To the Saints of God most dear.
We rejoice to see his seventy fifth birth-day.
May blessing rich from Heaven
Freely unto him be given,
And Angels give him comfort night and day.

chorus:

O God bless thy servant Brigham,
Prolong his life for many a year,
To guide us to thy praise
We saints of Latter days,
And the honest hearts in all the world to cheer.

God blessings on him send,
On this the world's best friend,
Who so manfully has stood the trying hour.
He's been faithful to his God.
And held fast the " Iron Rod",
And Almighty God has led him by his power.

chorus

And May he live to see,
The Power and Majesty
Of the holy Priesthood reigning o'er the earth.
And many Temples stand
On this consecrated land,
And bless the goodly day that gave him birth.

chorus

~~~~~~
Of course, Young’s life was not “prolong[ed] … for many a year,” and he did not “live to see … many Temples stand [o]n this consecrated land.” He died about fifteen months later, having seen the completion of a single temple in Utah.
“We live by faith, not by sight” (2 For. 5:7 NIV).
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by drumdude »

Another Monday, and another slow decline in the daily average.

Image

The Becoming Brigham team accidentally posted episode 21 early. This was quickly removed before anyone had a chance to pirate the wildly popular series and distribute it to the millions of faithful fans.

It’s definitely not a sign that the episodes are all so similar and dull, that the BB team themselves can’t keep them straight. :lol:
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by drumdude »

Nothing too exciting today (and Becoming Brigham viewers seem to agree!). Just more steady decline in the interest of this long drawn out boring vanity project.

Image

Maybe Dan can relate this to the story of Job in a faith promoting way.
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by drumdude »

I missed the previous installment of Becoming Brigham last week (as did most Mormons). Nothing new, just more slow decline.

Image

Image
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: The Vanishing Act: How The Afore Turned 32,000 Viewers Into A Literal Ghost Town

Post by drumdude »

I’ve been too busy to keep tabs on the series but it seems that the viewership is slowly increasing. Dan just posted a request for people to spread the word about the show.

I wonder how many people he think would be interested in this series, even if it was produced by Stephen Spielberg himself.

Why is Dan not satisfied with his current viewership?
Post Reply