Smith was an opportunist so he latched onto anything in the Bible to support his desires. Really telling how God's commandments have to be kept secret which is another example of the weak god syndrome. Wgs.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:07 pmMy understanding is that having multiple wives was cultural and nothing to do with what God did or did not want. Wives were a status signal, a power move by the wealthy to maintain dynastic control. It certainly wasn’t how the Church portrays it in their excusing of Smith’s rampant philandering.Rivendale wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 9:49 pmI guess it could be interpreted that when David was gifted Saul's kingdom including his wives that god didn't explicitly condem it. Dan McClellan says that polygamy in the ancient world was ubiquitous and it didn't seem abhorrent therefor it didn't influence the writers one way or another. There are conflicting scriptures but that is normal for the Bible.
Joe's Ranch
- Rivendale
- God
- Posts: 2030
- Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2021 5:21 pm
Re: Joe's Ranch
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: Joe's Ranch
In this discussion I think it it’s important to keep a balanced view of what was going on in early LDS polygamy:
It’s interesting that there was quite a range in age among Joseph’s wives. I think one of the first three or so was actually pregnant from her husband when she was sealed to Joseph. Anyway, as one studies early Mormon polygamy it is important to keep an open mind. As I said in a recent post on this thread, cultural practices and taboos play a part in how we view this topic along with others.
Keep balanced! Usually it’s not ‘all or nothing’.
You might see things differently and/or as an all or nothing sort of thing. I can see how you might think that. I remember doing so. Not that it wasn’t rather messy in some instances. In others, like the quote I gave says, both men and women involved testified of spiritual witnesses they received letting them know the practice was from God.
Regards,
MG
When some folks get worked up about polygamy it is good to keep in mind it wasn’t some kind of mass hypnosis where women were being sucked in. Yes, there was pressure put on some of the women as they were told their eternal salvation rested on saying “yes”. I’m not on board with that if it happened in the way some describe.Both women and men testified of receiving powerful spiritual witnesses that it was God’s will for them to participate in this practice.
The Lord did not reveal His reasons for restoring plural marriage. However, the Book of Mormon, while prohibiting polygamy generally, explains that God sometimes commands it in order to “raise up seed unto [Him].” Plural marriage among the early Saints did result in the birth of many children into faithful Latter-day Saint families in a relatively short time. This helped to strengthen the early Church, and many Latter-day Saints today can trace their roots to those families.
Church website.
It’s interesting that there was quite a range in age among Joseph’s wives. I think one of the first three or so was actually pregnant from her husband when she was sealed to Joseph. Anyway, as one studies early Mormon polygamy it is important to keep an open mind. As I said in a recent post on this thread, cultural practices and taboos play a part in how we view this topic along with others.
Keep balanced! Usually it’s not ‘all or nothing’.
You might see things differently and/or as an all or nothing sort of thing. I can see how you might think that. I remember doing so. Not that it wasn’t rather messy in some instances. In others, like the quote I gave says, both men and women involved testified of spiritual witnesses they received letting them know the practice was from God.
Regards,
MG
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: Joe's Ranch
Keep balanced lol
Yes, that’s some advice and a way to look at it. Balance the proper amount of concern we should have about a religious leader using eternal salvation as leverage to obtain additional wives.
Unequivocal condemnation of religious coercion would be a reasonably balanced approach, whether some women sincerely embraced polygamy or not.
Yes, that’s some advice and a way to look at it. Balance the proper amount of concern we should have about a religious leader using eternal salvation as leverage to obtain additional wives.
Unequivocal condemnation of religious coercion would be a reasonably balanced approach, whether some women sincerely embraced polygamy or not.
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: Joe's Ranch
Hi Limnor, in response to yourLimnor wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 11:56 pmKeep balanced lol
Yes, that’s some advice and a way to look at it. Balance the proper amount of concern we should have about a religious leader using eternal salvation as leverage to obtain additional wives.
Unequivocal condemnation of religious coercion would be a reasonably balanced approach, whether some women sincerely embraced polygamy or not.
Literally.
Are there things that I may not know or have insight...be privy...to? Of course. Obviously. But I've been around the block.
I know you are well studied and think you know things inside and out...but really, you don't know what it's like on the inside. I'm not trying to be exclusivist here, I'm just stating the reality.
I read what you say, punctuated with an lol, and I'm skeptical as to whether or not you have a handle/insight on everything there is to know...including the experiences that members of the church have had as the Spirit whispers to them that the Restoration narrative is true in its essential components.
Normally I wouldn't bring up the witness of the Spirit because it can be seen as a get out of jail free card. But it is part of the whole equation. I know there are Evangelical sorts that say prayer is not part of the process in determining the truth claims of the LDS Church. Deuteronomy and all that. That never made sense to me. It may to you.
If so, we are coming at things from different angles and will not view or see things the same way because of our perspective.
Anyway, "unequivocal condemnation" should be temporized when one is judging something without full disclosure/information. And then only in isolation looking at one thing rather than condemning the whole.
Thank you for looking at things from the point of view of someone who is actually an anti-Mormon trying to undermine the church.
Not really. Just razzin ya'.
I hope Marcus doesn't take the anti-Mormon comment out of context and paint me something I'm not!
Hope this helps.
Regards,
MG
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: Joe's Ranch
One doesn’t have to be a Mormon to recognize that using religion, including the threat of losing one’s eternal salvation, to coerce someone into marriage, is wrong.
I’m condemning religious coercion. Surely that’s something we can agree on, regardless of being inside or outside a particular faith tradition.
I’m condemning religious coercion. Surely that’s something we can agree on, regardless of being inside or outside a particular faith tradition.
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: Joe's Ranch
Yes. And I think I mentioned that. I think it is important to being it up again although, truth be told, it's been brought up many times over the years.Limnor wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 12:31 amOne doesn’t have to be a Mormon to recognize that using religion, including the threat of losing one’s eternal salvation, to coerce someone into marriage, is wrong.
I’m condemning religious coercion. Surely that’s something we can agree on, regardless of being inside or outside a particular faith tradition.
Regards,
MG
-
Marcus
- God
- Posts: 8297
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm
Re: Joe's Ranch
Yes, this is definitely one of the situations where the strategy of balance, meeting half-way, finding the middle road or whatever people want to call it is nothing more than a particularly disturbing logical fallacy.Limnor wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 11:56 pmKeep balanced lol
Yes, that’s some advice and a way to look at it. Balance the proper amount of concern we should have about a religious leader using eternal salvation as leverage to obtain additional wives.
Unequivocal condemnation of religious coercion would be a reasonably balanced approach, whether some women sincerely embraced polygamy or not.
-
Philo Sofee
- God
- Posts: 6145
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am
Re: Joe's Ranch
Why are you so concerned about what other people think of you? You DO realize that for that to change, you are the one who has to genuinely initiate it, right? I believe 3/4 of your problems are shooting yourself in the foot because it concerns you so much about what other people think...MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 12:20 amHi Limnor, in response to yourLimnor wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 11:56 pmKeep balanced lol
Yes, that’s some advice and a way to look at it. Balance the proper amount of concern we should have about a religious leader using eternal salvation as leverage to obtain additional wives.
Unequivocal condemnation of religious coercion would be a reasonably balanced approach, whether some women sincerely embraced polygamy or not.response to my suggestion of balance I would say that there may be a difference between you and me in the sense that I'm on the inside and you're on the outside looking in. I've been in the church all my life. I think in some respects I know it inside out.
Literally.
Are there things that I may not know or have insight...be privy...to? Of course. Obviously. But I've been around the block.
I know you are well studied and think you know things inside and out...but really, you don't know what it's like on the inside. I'm not trying to be exclusivist here, I'm just stating the reality.
I read what you say, punctuated with an lol, and I'm skeptical as to whether or not you have a handle/insight on everything there is to know...including the experiences that members of the church have had as the Spirit whispers to them that the Restoration narrative is true in its essential components.
Normally I wouldn't bring up the witness of the Spirit because it can be seen as a get out of jail free card. But it is part of the whole equation. I know there are Evangelical sorts that say prayer is not part of the process in determining the truth claims of the LDS Church. Deuteronomy and all that. That never made sense to me. It may to you.
If so, we are coming at things from different angles and will not view or see things the same way because of our perspective.
Anyway, "unequivocal condemnation" should be temporized when one is judging something without full disclosure/information. And then only in isolation looking at one thing rather than condemning the whole.
Thank you for looking at things from the point of view of someone who is actually an anti-Mormon trying to undermine the church.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Not really. Just razzin ya'.
I hope Marcus doesn't take the anti-Mormon comment out of context and paint me something I'm not!
Hope this helps.
Regards,
MG
-
I Have Questions
- God
- Posts: 4579
- Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am
Re: Joe's Ranch
This is 37 year old Smith using religion to try and coerce 19 year old Nancy Rigdon to sleep with him.Rivendale wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:40 pmSmith was an opportunist so he latched onto anything in the Bible to support his desires. Really telling how God's commandments have to be kept secret which is another example of the weak god syndrome. Wgs.I Have Questions wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:07 pmMy understanding is that having multiple wives was cultural and nothing to do with what God did or did not want. Wives were a status signal, a power move by the wealthy to maintain dynastic control. It certainly wasn’t how the Church portrays it in their excusing of Smith’s rampant philandering.
It is also worth remembering that at the time Smith held a position of authority over Nancy.Happiness is the object and design of our existence, and will be the end thereof if we pursue the path that leads to it; and this path is virtue, uprightness, faithfulness, holiness, and keeping all the commandments of God. But we cannot keep all the commandments without first knowing them, and we cannot expect to know all, or more than we now know, unless we comply with or keep those we have already received. That which is wrong under one circumstance, may be, and often is, right under another. God said thou shalt not kill,—1 at another time he said thou shalt utterly destroy.2 This is the principle on which the government of heaven is conducted—by revelation adapted to the circumstances in which the children of the kingdom are placed. Whatever God requires is right, no matter what it is, although we may not see the reason thereof till long after the events transpire.
Sexual coercion is when a person pressures, tricks, threatens, or manipulates someone into sex. It is a type of sexual assault because even if someone says yes, they are not giving their consent freely.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
- canpakes
- God
- Posts: 10718
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:25 am
Re: Joe's Ranch
MG,MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 12:20 amHi Limnor, in response to yourLimnor wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 11:56 pmKeep balanced lol
Yes, that’s some advice and a way to look at it. Balance the proper amount of concern we should have about a religious leader using eternal salvation as leverage to obtain additional wives.
Unequivocal condemnation of religious coercion would be a reasonably balanced approach, whether some women sincerely embraced polygamy or not.response to my suggestion of balance I would say that there may be a difference between you and me in the sense that I'm on the inside and you're on the outside looking in. I've been in the church all my life. I think in some respects I know it inside out.
Literally.
Are there things that I may not know or have insight...be privy...to? Of course. Obviously. But I've been around the block.
I know you are well studied and think you know things inside and out...but really, you don't know what it's like on the inside. I'm not trying to be exclusivist here, I'm just stating the reality.
I read what you say, punctuated with an lol, and I'm skeptical as to whether or not you have a handle/insight on everything there is to know...including the experiences that members of the church have had as the Spirit whispers to them that the Restoration narrative is true in its essential components.
Normally I wouldn't bring up the witness of the Spirit because it can be seen as a get out of jail free card. But it is part of the whole equation. I know there are Evangelical sorts that say prayer is not part of the process in determining the truth claims of the LDS Church. Deuteronomy and all that. That never made sense to me. It may to you.
If so, we are coming at things from different angles and will not view or see things the same way because of our perspective.
Anyway, "unequivocal condemnation" should be temporized when one is judging something without full disclosure/information. And then only in isolation looking at one thing rather than condemning the whole.
Thank you for looking at things from the point of view of someone who is actually an anti-Mormon trying to undermine the church.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Not really. Just razzin ya'.
I hope Marcus doesn't take the anti-Mormon comment out of context and paint me something I'm not!
Hope this helps.
Regards,
MG
This boils down to a claim that no one outside the Church can draw reasonable conclusions about the practice of polygamy because only the members receive the whispers from God that end up rationalizing it.