I think it’s an important question. Do you think Joseph was commanded to commit adultery and only reluctantly participated?
I think the historical evidence is quite compelling that he conducted it in secret and used a backdated revelation as cover and as a means to expand the adultery.
I think that he was commanded to take plural wives. I also think that he kept it secret. I don’t think that he did so as a means to “expand adultery”.
I think it’s an important question. Do you think Joseph was commanded to commit adultery and only reluctantly participated?
I think the historical evidence is quite compelling that he conducted it in secret and used a backdated revelation as cover and as a means to expand the adultery.
It’s identical to the tactics men use to cheat on their wives every day. Lies, secrecy, gaslighting, etc. None of that was a part of the Abraham and Issac story.
I'd like to hear mg's answer as well.
I thought the historical evidence was pretty clear, but to hear that excuse proffered here, apparently in all seriousness, was a shock!
I think it’s an important question. Do you think Joseph was commanded to commit adultery and only reluctantly participated?
I think the historical evidence is quite compelling that he conducted it in secret and used a backdated revelation as cover and as a means to expand the adultery.
It’s identical to the tactics men use to cheat on their wives every day. Lies, secrecy, gaslighting, etc. None of that was a part of the Abraham and Issac story.
I think the smoking gun in all of this is that the command to commit adultery came after Joseph had already commenced the practice of sleeping with as many women and young girls as he could get his hands on. Joseph tended to get revelations retrospectively, after people had queried and challenged his bad behaviour.
Last edited by I Have Questions on Thu Oct 29, 2026 9:12 am, edited 2 times in total.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
I think it’s an important question. Do you think Joseph was commanded to commit adultery and only reluctantly participated?
I think the historical evidence is quite compelling that he conducted it in secret and used a backdated revelation as cover and as a means to expand the adultery.
I think that he was commanded to take plural wives. I also think that he kept it secret. I don’t think that he did so as a means to “expand adultery”.
Regards,
MG
Why in the world would you follow a God who does this? Is he so weak that he has to command his creation to do immoral activity to reach his goals? We see this repeatedly in the Bible and Book of Mormon where a simple cerebral aneurism solves the problem yet we need carnage like beheading a drunken man or bashing infant's heads on rocks. He requires men to do the the dirty work?
I think that he was commanded to take plural wives. I also think that he kept it secret. I don’t think that he did so as a means to “expand adultery”.
Regards,
MG
Why in the world would you follow a God who does this? Is he so weak that he has to command his creation to do immoral activity to reach his goals? We see this repeatedly in the Bible and Book of Mormon where a simple cerebral aneurism solves the problem yet we need carnage like beheading a drunken man or bashing infant's heads on rocks. He requires men to do the the dirty work?
It’s a tough call to try and rationalize some of the things that pass as God’s commands. I’ve often thought that the Lord may have been better off taking care of Laman and Lemuel before they caused SO MUCH havoc. And the generations that lived ‘unrighteously’ because they were allowed to live. This scenario can be multiplied by the thousands across the planet over the span of human existence.
From our perspective it is very difficult to accept and explain why God might step in on one situation and not another. I don’t have an answer that has been satisfactory for me. Things seem to happen in a somewhat random fashion with some serendipity thrown in for good measure.
The million dollar question is whether one can maintain confidence that God’s purposes are accomplished even with all the chaos and mayhem which has many different faces and expressions. Some people have a higher threshold for accepting ‘Gods will’ than others.
How much of the “bashing of heads” is God’s commands vs. men doing bad things and later calling it God’s will is open to question as one peers through the historical lens.
I’ve often thought that the Lord may have been better off taking care of Laman and Lemuel before they caused SO MUCH havoc.
I've often thought the Lord should have taken care of the self-righteous prig Nephi before HE caused so much trouble by his judgmental driving off half the family.
mg wrote:
...The million dollar question is whether one can maintain confidence that God’s purposes are accomplished even with all the chaos and mayhem which has many different faces and expressions. Some people have a higher threshold for accepting ‘Gods will’ than others...
Is that another way of saying that much gullibility is required to continue believing "god's will" is a real thing even though the evidence indicates otherwise?
Why in the world would you follow a God who does this? Is he so weak that he has to command his creation to do immoral activity to reach his goals? We see this repeatedly in the Bible and Book of Mormon where a simple cerebral aneurism solves the problem yet we need carnage like beheading a drunken man or bashing infant's heads on rocks. He requires men to do the the dirty work?
It’s a tough call to try and rationalize some of the things that pass as God’s commands. I’ve often thought that the Lord may have been better off taking care of Laman and Lemuel before they caused SO MUCH havoc. And the generations that lived ‘unrighteously’ because they were allowed to live. This scenario can be multiplied by the thousands across the planet over the span of human existence.
From our perspective it is very difficult to accept and explain why God might step in on one situation and not another. I don’t have an answer that has been satisfactory for me. Things seem to happen in a somewhat random fashion with some serendipity thrown in for good measure.
The million dollar question is whether one can maintain confidence that God’s purposes are accomplished even with all the chaos and mayhem which has many different faces and expressions. Some people have a higher threshold for accepting ‘Gods will’ than others.
How much of the “bashing of heads” is God’s commands vs. men doing bad things and later calling it God’s will is open to question as one peers through the historical lens.
Regards,
MG
You presuppose god is real and that is the crux of the problem because as Steven Weinberg quoted....
With or without religion, good people can behave well and bad people can do evil; but for good people to do evil — that takes religion
Which leads to an assortment of hypotheticals like "he was speaking as a man" or that was just an evil act propagated by an evil person. It also curates perpetual thought stopping by asserting God's ways are mysterious and god sees the bigger picture. First Corinthians 13:11 should be taken serious..
When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put aside childish ways
Rather than being the crux of "a problem" as you espouse/see it, I see belief in God as the catalyst to further thought, introspection, and inquiry. Going without God creates a dead end and even a blind spot when seeking for further light and knowledge.
That has been my experience anyway.
At its root, that is why so many of these conversations are so polarized. We are coming at things with world/God views that are diametrically opposed.