I Have Questions wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 11:34 am
I note that the believing Mormons over on the MD&D board are almost universally against Elder Cook’s inspired counsel. Many think Cook is being naïve, that his counsel is “foolish”, that he is clueless as to the risks (especially to women) of removing their anonymity. Some have even suggested that they don’t trust the Church to not pursue them for their online activity were they to reveal themselves.
This has always been true. You may not have been around for the founding of "MAD", but the base doctrine of the faction that got that board started was "postmodern" interpretations of Mormonism that said people who believe in literal prophets are naiive. Their own higher educations tell them that Joseph Smith had a license to do whatever he damn well pleased and there was literally nothing that would stop him from being a prophet because the definition of a prophet isn't what we think it is. They never could explain themselves here -- it's basically just the same thing as MG, have cake and eat too, but with some window dressing from university writers on religion who were popular at the time.
The first level of this charade sounds insane. Since none of the old-school participants on that board believe in a prophet anymore than you or I, why spend 10% of your income paying for what you can get for free "doing what's right in your own eyes"? Why do what is right in your own eyes, and then pay 10% of your income as if it's coming from somebody you explicitly reject as a prophet?
Okay, my guess is that very, very few of those who employ relativism is large doses to defend the church are paying a full 10% tithing on their gross. I'd bet my 401k that neither MG nor any principal poster at MAD/FAIR is paying a full 10%. But they are probably paying something, but why even pay that?
Okay, there's a reason. You've admitted your church is false, that there is no such thing as prophets, but you want to maintain social ties, and that costs something. To stay in the club, maybe a 4% tithing and an hour of church a week (or two depending if you feel like it) while not just skipping the counsel of the prophets but
laughing at people who are gullible enough to take it literally as fundamentalists or black-and-white-thinkers.
Okay, this does make some sense. No doubt these folks sit back in church feeling as if they are the elite, enlightened members. Consider how MG considers himself near the top of Fowler's stages of faith. So they see themselves as the "Star bellied Sneetches". They walk around church with their heads held high, laughing at people like my parents who took it literally. So now we can see why there is still social value to maintaining ties with the faith you've explicitly rejected, especially given that this can be maintained with little effort. Similar to wealth distinction. "Oh look at how rich I am and I don't have to work." Same thing. Makes sense.
But where it really starts to get really morally gray is in their full support of the church such as it is. It's one thing to think people like my parents were deluded fundamentalists who shot themselves in the foot because they couldn't think for themselves, and to actively encourage the church to expand its power and influence and go full steam ahead with bringing people into the church who like my parents, will be tricked into thinking prophets actually are real and that tithing is 10% on their gross income. Why sabotage the lives of innocent bystanders like this?